
Originally Posted by
Alistair

Originally Posted by
Frug
I think this thread summarizes the whole gun debate nicely.
Considered replying.
Realized futility of replying.
Posted empty reply anyway.
/shrug
I love me some FHC, but the Ameri-hate, Eurocentric, Liberal/Socialist viewpoint of the majority here puts the few individualist libertarians (like me) and conservatives in a no-win situation. We'll be shouted down and insulted no matter what we say or think.
This is another thing I don't get.. You aren't being responded to in an outrageously offensive manner, but by people responding calmly with a number of well established arguments as to why gun control (in countries where guns aren't as proliferate) was thought up, and why it has a number of listed beneficial effects on gun incidents and crimes, as based on a global statistics from a compilation of countries that exceed the size and population of the USA.
Instead of seemingly even considering that perhaps your opinion isn't as logically justified as you thought, and rationally going through all the arguments in your head and then making an educated decision based on the information at hand, you flat out dismiss any form of debate, mutual consensus or discussion by citing that those disagreeing with you here are implied to be of a certain demographic group (eurocentric, anti-american, liberal majority) that are out to "Shout down and insult" well intentioned conservatives, and that no matter how you respond you are in a "no-win situation".
I mean, you don't seem like a hillbilly, and I consider it important to respect and not judge people I disagree with, so I'm going to assume you are an intelligent man, sir. Can you not see, then, how you are employing (probably unintentionally) every flawed rhetoric in the proverbial book, and shutting down any possible avenue of debate by staunchly refusing to consider (and let me point out there is a fundamental difference between "admitting you're wrong" and "considering you COULD be wrong") that your perspective may not be reliably and logically sound.
I'm not advocating for you to repent and admit "defeat", because I understand that would be contra-productive and for most people (perhaps not you, I don't know you) would involve Pride in the matter, which would unnecessarily complicate matters.
But I am asking you to do the rational, logical thing and critically deconstruct your own opinions and attempt to find flawed reasoning in your own rationale. It's the intelligent thing to do, and I would like to consider you an intelligent man.
Bookmarks