
Originally Posted by
Keckers

Originally Posted by
Lallante
Fully in favour of it in a consumer context. What power do we have if not to choose where and what to consume based on our values?
Fully against it in an academic context.
Needs to be proportionate and goal-oriented rather than punative in any context.
Fair enough
What power do we have if not to choose where and what to consume based on our values?
This is where I have questions. What values can ever be appropriately signaled through consumer choice when faced with the practical reality of society? Aren't our consumer choices disproportionately limited by the consumption choices we are offered rather than the consumption choices we demand?
And what about the fact we exist as a duality of consumer and product? Workers also ultimately exist as both producer and consumer.
It's hard to overstate how much companies individually and the market collectively responds to consumer trends (and the political trends which arise from popular support).
You can be cynical about it (like anything else, what's new?) because it is profit-seeking behaviour, and insist it doesnt go far enough but statistically the impact is massive and not merely tokenistic. The rise of organic food, renewable power supply companies and consumer rejection of palm oil are three great examples - the entire markets (and consumption choices available) have shifted as a response to socially-conscious consumer trends, and the results have changed the entire supply chains for not just these goods but related ones. There are loads more examples (car mileage / electric vehicles, ethical clothing production, fair trade etc). You can pooh pooh these impacts but I doubt you could provide evidence of their insubstantiality.
What's your point about the duality? Isnt that merely a matter of context? You mean that in some cases your motivations in both roles might conflict? E.g. an environmentally conscious coal miner? Isn't the defining nature of principles that sometimes one must act against ones own interest in support of them?
Bookmarks