PDA

View Full Version : [Mafia] Witch Hunt



Lana Torrin
February 22 2013, 11:28:21 PM
The town meeting was about to start. After the horrible death of the pastor and his 2 children, the crops failing and last nights eerie full moon, the villagers were scared. It was obvious to all that their town had been marked by witches. There was only one solution and everyone knew what had to be done. The witches needed to be found and killed as soon as possible or they would take this town for there own, dooming everyone to an eternity in hell.

Roles
3x Witches
1x Priest
Roles were drawn completely at random (Go go magic powershell)

Players
Kilabi - Witch
Navigator Six - Villager
LarkinAlpha
Nicho Void - Villager
Victoria Steckersaurus - Villager
pratell
duckduck - Priest
Qwert - Villager
ctrlchris
Me - Witch
DrumWithMe2012 - Villager
Cue1* - Villager

Voting

Day 1

Cue1* - Qwert, LarkinAlpha, DrumWithMe2012, ctrlchris, Kilabi, pratell
DrumWithMe2012 - Navigator Six, Cue1*, cullnean, Victoria Steckersaurus
Victoria Steckersaurus - Me, Nicho Void

Abstain/Not Voted - No one

Cue1* was drowned and found to be a villager
Nicho Void was killed by the witches and found to be a villager


Day 2

DrumWithMe2012 - ctrlchris, Navigator Six, Qwert, duckduck
LarkinAlpha - Me, DrumWithMe2012, pratell
Me - Kilabi, LarkinAlpha

Abstain/Not Voted - Victoria Steckersaurus

DrumWithMe2012 was burnt and found to be a villager.



Day 3

Victoria Steckersaurus - Qwert, LarkinAlpha, Kilabi, Me, pratell
LarkinAlpha - ctrlchris
Me - DuckDuck
ctrlchris - Navigator Six

Abstain/Not Voted - Victoria Steckersaurus

Victoria was hung and found to be a villager


Day 4

I'll add them up in a bit.. Basically everyone voted for Me..
Abstain/Not Voted -

Me was burnt and found to be a Witch.
Duckduck was burnt by the witches and found to be the priest.


Day 5

I'll add them up in a bit.. Basically everyone voted for Kilabi.. Funny that..
Abstain/Not Voted -

Kilabi was burnt and found to be a witch.
Qwert was killed by the witches and found to be a villager.
Navigator 6 was killed by the witches and found to be a villager.



Day 6

Abstain/Not Voted -




Voting ends at 1am GMT Saturday 2nd

Me
February 22 2013, 11:33:31 PM
http://www.abc.net.au/news/2013-02-07/woman-burned-alive-for-sorcery-in-png/4506452

irl

Qwert
February 22 2013, 11:45:12 PM
Lets get the ball rolling with $Cue1*. Only a witch could possibly conceive of such a :psyduck: game of Mafia.

pratell
February 23 2013, 01:11:46 AM
$Qwert because he needs to focus on Tribal Hero.

Cue1*
February 23 2013, 01:17:23 AM
Victoria Steckersaurus. She's been mafia all but the one game I ran.
the thing from the buzz buzz

LarkinAlpha
February 23 2013, 02:03:48 AM
Lets get the ball rolling with $Cue1*. Only a witch could possibly conceive of such a :psyduck: game of Mafia.

I'm going to second this vote. $Cue1*, simply because Bent is not playing.

Navigator Six
February 23 2013, 08:50:33 AM
I don't understand why you're not going about this scientifically; you're basically just randomly guessing people! Clearly the witches got here recently, so the most appropriate choice is the newest person around.

$DrumWithMe2012

(I keep thinking of Ork Witches :?)

DrumWithMe2012
February 23 2013, 03:16:07 PM
I don't understand why you're not going about this scientifically; you're basically just randomly guessing people! Clearly the witches got here recently, so the most appropriate choice is the newest person around.

$DrumWithMe2012

(I keep thinking of Ork Witches :?)


Seeing as it takes more than a month for crops to fail over the course of the season, wouldn't it make the most sense that the newest one wouldn't be a witch?
Navigator Six

Navigator Six
February 23 2013, 03:21:21 PM
I don't understand why you're not going about this scientifically; you're basically just randomly guessing people! Clearly the witches got here recently, so the most appropriate choice is the newest person around.

$DrumWithMe2012

(I keep thinking of Ork Witches :?)


Seeing as it takes more than a month for crops to fail over the course of the season, wouldn't it make the most sense that the newest one wouldn't be a witch?
Navigator Six

Aaaaand he's obviously a witch. Get the ducks.

cullnean
February 23 2013, 03:29:23 PM
Which witch is which?

Tapatalk

Navigator Six
February 23 2013, 04:19:02 PM
Which witch is which?

Tapatalk

Duck duck duck duck duck duck GOOSE.

pratell
February 23 2013, 04:32:23 PM
I don't understand why you're not going about this scientifically; you're basically just randomly guessing people! Clearly the witches got here recently, so the most appropriate choice is the newest person around.

$DrumWithMe2012

(I keep thinking of Ork Witches :?)

three good mate

cullnean
February 23 2013, 05:21:22 PM
I don't understand why you're not going about this scientifically; you're basically just randomly guessing people! Clearly the witches got here recently, so the most appropriate choice is the newest person around.

$DrumWithMe2012
$DrumWithMe2012

(I keep thinking of Ork Witches :?)

three good mate


$DrumWithMe2012

Tapatalk

DrumWithMe2012
February 23 2013, 07:06:02 PM
navigator six
cueonestar

Cue1*
February 23 2013, 07:06:14 PM
victoria $DrumWithMe2012

Drum has been acting weird since she read Lana's PM. Clearly a witch.

the thing from the buzz buzz

Toxic
February 23 2013, 07:15:23 PM
Chris is a bitch.. I mean, witch :-P

Lana Torrin
February 24 2013, 12:03:52 AM
Chris is a bitch.. I mean, witch :-P
M8 m8 m8 m8... You arent even in this game..
Also vote tally updated

Me
February 24 2013, 12:42:16 AM
$Victoria Steckersaurus is always mafia, except when she is the idiot, but since there is no idiot this time that means Victoria must be mafia.

Q.E.D.

ctrlchris
February 24 2013, 02:02:37 AM
$Cueonewildcard

ctrlchris
February 24 2013, 02:03:09 AM
Reasoning: my brain still hurts from the last game.

Kilabi
February 24 2013, 08:15:30 AM
$Cueonewildcard

Sorry for posting late, i got the drunks. Joining this bandwagon for the clusterfuck last game :P

Lana Torrin
February 24 2013, 09:52:01 AM
$Cueonewildcard

Sorry for posting late, i got the drunks. Joining this bandwagon for the clusterfuck last game :P

Is that your vote? Votes updated except that one.

ctrlchris
February 24 2013, 09:59:54 AM
$Cueonewildcard

Sorry for posting late, i got the drunks. Joining this bandwagon for the clusterfuck last game :P

Is that your vote? Votes updated except that one.

"Joining this bandwagon"

Navigator Six
February 24 2013, 10:49:50 AM
Why do you have cull down as voting for me? 8-) (Unless it's a SIGN, in which case cull is obviously the priest, and I'm clearly a witch. Wait, no!)

Lana Torrin
February 24 2013, 11:26:21 AM
Why do you have cull down as voting for me? 8-) (Unless it's a SIGN, in which case cull is obviously the priest, and I'm clearly a witch. Wait, no!)

Lol copy paste fail.

If anyone can wake up Nicho and Victoria that would be awesome.

Kilabi
February 24 2013, 01:33:45 PM
$Cue1*

To make it clearer.

And yes, for making the last game a horror.

Do we get priest results right away or on day change?

Nicho Void
February 24 2013, 03:17:00 PM
$Victoria Steckersaurus

Victoria Steckersaurus
February 24 2013, 03:28:59 PM
Being that it's a first day vote, and these must be done more maximum lols and/or butthurt, and that somehow there is not yet a Nicho bandwagon (seriously guys what the fuck? dropping the ball here), let's see about $DrumWithMe2013 (cuz it's not 2012 anymore)

I, for one, am going to enjoy playing a game without a role for once. Ending up with a role in 5 straight games would be a bit silly (although everyone got roles in mafiOrks, so that one doesn't really count).

LarkinAlpha
February 24 2013, 06:15:24 PM
Being that it's a first day vote, and these must be done more maximum lols and/or butthurt, and that somehow there is not yet a Nicho bandwagon (seriously guys what the fuck? dropping the ball here), let's see about $DrumWithMe2013 (cuz it's not 2012 anymore)
Nicho's fuck ups pale in comparision to the power of the CuebiWon Wildcardodie. Besides we can just kill him next turn.


I, for one, am going to enjoy playing a game without a role for once. Ending up with a role in 5 straight games would be a bit silly (although everyone got roles in mafiOrks, so that one doesn't really count).
:D I'm also agreeing that the randomness leaves much to be desired.

Lana Torrin
February 24 2013, 09:39:33 PM
$Cue1*

To make it clearer.

And yes, for making the last game a horror.

Do we get priest results right away or on day change?

Right away, but my login times are a bit messed up so sometimes it might not make it till a few hours before the deadline.

Counts updated

Cue1*
February 24 2013, 11:00:42 PM
When Drum went out I read her PM from Lana. She's a witch.

the thing from the buzz buzz

Varcaus
February 24 2013, 11:06:10 PM
When Drum went out I read her PM from Lana. She's a witch.

the thing from the buzz buzz

o.o

Cue1*
February 24 2013, 11:25:46 PM
She just got home so she's going to post a bunch of denial in a minute. Don't believe her.

the thing from the buzz buzz

DrumWithMe2012
February 24 2013, 11:27:49 PM
When Drum went out I read her PM from Lana. She's a witch.

the thing from the buzz buzz

fuck. you. cue.

that's not what it said, by the way. In efforts to keep himself in the game, he can lie however he likes. But he doesn't know that I did the same while he was asleep last night. So take it as you will, but how do you know which one of us is lying? I would like to think I'm the truthful one here, given that last game, my information was stated as given, but I was the nut (just didn't know it until I got a PM from the other sheriff). Stating here for the record that I'm just a villager. Granted, I'll be gone in 24 hours so I suppose it won't matter. You can trust me and you'll maintain one more for the village or you can believe Cue and lose someone senselessly. Your choice. I can't exactly prove it yet, seeing as it's only the first round so good luck. And again, fuck you cue. nobody likes you anymore.

DrumWithMe2012
February 24 2013, 11:28:17 PM
cue isn't getting laid for a while.

Cue1*
February 24 2013, 11:29:01 PM
cue isn't getting laid for a while.

She's mad I exposed her so early.

the thing from the buzz buzz

Varcaus
February 24 2013, 11:29:12 PM
:shitshit::psyduck::popcorn:

DrumWithMe2012
February 24 2013, 11:34:28 PM
cue isn't getting laid for a while.

She's mad I exposed her so early.

the thing from the buzz buzz


No, simply mad that he lied. Flat out lied. So I have a suggestion. To prove that Mr. CueOneStar is not trustworthy, keep your vote for me. I'll play the next game. You lose a villager and will be left with the dishonest one. Until then, my friends.

spasm
February 24 2013, 11:46:40 PM
Cue is obviously the village idiot.

pratell
February 24 2013, 11:50:24 PM
$Qwert

$Cue*1*

Lana Torrin
February 25 2013, 12:01:00 AM
The village has spoken, Cue1* must be a witch. He knows too much to be a villiger, he must have some sort of powers. A DROWNING! If he floats hes a witch and will be burnt.

The villgers grab Cue, tie him up, gag him and take him to the river. Tieing rocks to his feet they dump him in. He sinks. They wait... And wait.. He does not come back up.

Perhaps witches drown? Confused the villigers retire for the night.

Later that night Nicho Void wakes in great pain. He gasps for air but there is no one around to help him. Clutching at his heart he almost makes it to the door before passing out. The village finds his already rotting body in the morning.

Cue1* was drowned and found to be a villager
Nicho Void was killed by the witches and found to be a villager

(Yeah it was 48 hours, we started friday/saturday, check the time of your PM)

Cue1*
February 25 2013, 12:02:32 AM
Its time. Writeup incoming.

Thought it was a 48 hour day?

the thing from the buzz buzz

Cue1*
February 25 2013, 12:03:10 AM
Cue is obviously the village idiot.

There's no village idiot.

the thing from the buzz buzz

pratell
February 25 2013, 12:03:43 AM
Its time. Writeup incoming.

Thought it was a 48 hour day?

the thing from the buzz buzz
it started friday m8

Cue1*
February 25 2013, 12:04:52 AM
Its time. Writeup incoming.

Thought it was a 48 hour day?

the thing from the buzz buzz
it started friday m8

Just realized that, thought it went to Monday my time. Oops.

the thing from the buzz buzz

DrumWithMe2012
February 25 2013, 12:09:05 AM
Well that was quick. There's absolutely no convincing evidence out on the table yet for tomorrow....

Lana Torrin
February 25 2013, 12:16:59 AM
Well that was quick. There's absolutely no convincing evidence out on the table yet for tomorrow....

Yeah.. First day is 48h = good. First day is a friday/saturday - bad... If I run another one (and im having fun so far) im going to start it on a monday.

Also, a clarification on the witches voting (as it may contain some info). They don't know each other at the start so they vote the same as the village (except its not public obviously). As we have 3 witches, if they all disagree, no one dies, if 2 agree then 1 person dies, if all 3 agree they get a 2nd vote, and more than likely someone else will die as well (same rules though, so if they all vote for someone else on the 2nd vote, only 1 person dies).

pratell
February 25 2013, 12:24:11 AM
Well that was quick. There's absolutely no convincing evidence out on the table yet for tomorrow....

Yeah.. First day is 48h = good. First day is a friday/saturday - bad... If I run another one (and im having fun so far) im going to start it on a monday.

Also, a clarification on the witches voting (as it may contain some info). They don't know each other at the start so they vote the same as the village (except its not public obviously). As we have 3 witches, if they all disagree, no one dies, if 2 agree then 1 person dies, if all 3 agree they get a 2nd vote, and more than likely someone else will die as well (same rules though, so if they all vote for someone else on the 2nd vote, only 1 person dies).
so every turn:

1. Someone gets lynched.
2. If the witches secret vote to hex for three different people, no one dies.
3. If two witches secret vote to hex for the same person, that person dies.
4. If all three witches secret vote for the same person, that person dies, and additionally another vote is held subject to the rules 2 & 3 above.

c/d?

pratell
February 25 2013, 12:27:02 AM
Well that was quick. There's absolutely no convincing evidence out on the table yet for tomorrow....

i'm conviced you're a witch irl

Lana Torrin
February 25 2013, 12:30:10 AM
Well that was quick. There's absolutely no convincing evidence out on the table yet for tomorrow....

Yeah.. First day is 48h = good. First day is a friday/saturday - bad... If I run another one (and im having fun so far) im going to start it on a monday.

Also, a clarification on the witches voting (as it may contain some info). They don't know each other at the start so they vote the same as the village (except its not public obviously). As we have 3 witches, if they all disagree, no one dies, if 2 agree then 1 person dies, if all 3 agree they get a 2nd vote, and more than likely someone else will die as well (same rules though, so if they all vote for someone else on the 2nd vote, only 1 person dies).
so every turn:

1. Someone gets lynched.
2. If the witches secret vote to hex for three different people, no one dies.
3. If two witches secret vote to hex for the same person, that person dies.
4. If all three witches secret vote for the same person, that person dies, and additionally another vote is held subject to the rules 2 & 3 above.

c/d?

Correct. Except I make them tell me both votes at the same time so if they fluke all getting the same person in vote 1 it doesn't tell them anything.

I was actually surprised they managed to kill someone on the first turn and will be interested to find out if it was a fluke or not. Before the game started I figured it would be 3 or 4 turns before they got their first kill.

pratell
February 25 2013, 12:46:40 AM
Well that was quick. There's absolutely no convincing evidence out on the table yet for tomorrow....

Yeah.. First day is 48h = good. First day is a friday/saturday - bad... If I run another one (and im having fun so far) im going to start it on a monday.

Also, a clarification on the witches voting (as it may contain some info). They don't know each other at the start so they vote the same as the village (except its not public obviously). As we have 3 witches, if they all disagree, no one dies, if 2 agree then 1 person dies, if all 3 agree they get a 2nd vote, and more than likely someone else will die as well (same rules though, so if they all vote for someone else on the 2nd vote, only 1 person dies).
so every turn:

1. Someone gets lynched.
2. If the witches secret vote to hex for three different people, no one dies.
3. If two witches secret vote to hex for the same person, that person dies.
4. If all three witches secret vote for the same person, that person dies, and additionally another vote is held subject to the rules 2 & 3 above.

c/d?

Correct. Except I make them tell me both votes at the same time so if they fluke all getting the same person in vote 1 it doesn't tell them anything.

I was actually surprised they managed to kill someone on the first turn and will be interested to find out if it was a fluke or not. Before the game started I figured it would be 3 or 4 turns before they got their first kill.

except that it was nicho, are you really all that surprised

Me
February 25 2013, 12:57:14 AM
Pro-tier metagaming on the previous page.

ctrlchris
February 25 2013, 01:07:52 AM
I dont think cue actually read drums pm's, before spasms game he wanted to make sure everyone was ok with him and drum sharing a pc, and thus the chance to see pm's etc.

+ its a bit of a dick move *if* she is a which and cue is likely to be a better bloke then that.

So, either it was planned by the two of them for whatever reason or cue is actually a dick.

pratell
February 25 2013, 01:18:37 AM
cue is actually a dick.c.f. last mafia game

Qwert
February 25 2013, 01:20:04 AM
I dont think cue actually read drums pm's, before spasms game he wanted to make sure everyone was ok with him and drum sharing a pc, and thus the chance to see pm's etc.

+ its a bit of a dick move *if* she is a which and cue is likely to be a better bloke then that.

So, either it was planned by the two of them for whatever reason or cue is actually a dick.

Considering he made her nut on purpose...

LarkinAlpha
February 25 2013, 02:26:07 AM
When Drum went out I read her PM from Lana. She's a witch.

the thing from the buzz buzz

fuck. you. cue.


cue isn't getting laid for a while.

Ho ho ho.



cue is actually a dick.c.f. last mafia game

CCC. Also not sure who to vote for next. It was going to be Nicho, but the witches got him. Drum is the only lead, and she's deflecting like you would expect. Hrmm...

Cue1*
February 25 2013, 02:54:11 AM
So I know I'm dead and all, but I really need to say this.



cue isn't getting laid for a while.

Ho ho ho.


http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lQlIhraqL7o

the thing from the buzz buzz

Lana Torrin
February 25 2013, 03:01:37 AM
So I know I'm dead and all, but I really need to say this.



cue isn't getting laid for a while.

Ho ho ho.


http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lQlIhraqL7o

the thing from the buzz buzz

Congrats. Are you bruised? (also, can we move this to the OOG thread)

pratell
February 25 2013, 03:04:09 AM
inb4 pro-tier metagaming was clever ruse to opt out of game honorably so they can spread sheets rather than making spreadsheets.

ctrlchris
February 25 2013, 09:18:05 AM
So we are back to 24 hour days I assume?

For lack of a better idea $drumwithme subject to change if someone makes a good argument.

Lana Torrin
February 25 2013, 09:41:35 AM
So we are back to 24 hour days I assume?

For lack of a better idea $drumwithme subject to change if someone makes a good argument.

Yep 24h days from here on in.

Navigator Six
February 25 2013, 11:55:19 AM
So we are back to 24 hour days I assume?

For lack of a better idea $drumwithme subject to change if someone makes a good argument.

Poor Cue! This is what happens when you don't use logic. Chris has the correct approach.

$Drum

Qwert
February 25 2013, 04:16:36 PM
$drum

For now.

DrumWithMe2012
February 25 2013, 07:30:52 PM
Given previous games, Im usually out to be the innocent one. Last game, I was the but (by random assignment, not because Cue purposefully gave me that role). He says he read my message while I was out but he's not that much of an ass (at least not all the time) :) But since he didn't actually read my message, he had no idea that Im just a villager. You can believe Cue but when have I given you a reason not to trust me? Give me a chance to stick around.

DrumWithMe2012
February 25 2013, 07:35:17 PM
Also, Im finding that through the course of the mafia games, the members of the mafia tend to be quite shy and on the reserved side with few some times un-detailed posts. Again, that's just what I've observed. I would be more likely to suspect those who refrain from posts. Hence, I'm going with quert unless he can change my mind.

Qwert
February 25 2013, 07:45:12 PM
Only a witch would accuse a villager then not even spell his name right.

Seriously:
http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/thumb/0/0a/QWERTY_keyboard.jpg/640px-QWERTY_keyboard.jpg

Me
February 25 2013, 07:54:17 PM
$DrumWithMe2012

Kilabi
February 25 2013, 08:39:16 PM
I am not buying into the "i was innocent the last few games" argument, I still think the PM accusation is kind of weak.

§§Me for the confusing name and really short replies so far.

pratell
February 25 2013, 08:45:19 PM
$Drum

duckduck
February 25 2013, 09:08:23 PM
I'm going to follow the lynchmob and vote $Drum

Lana Torrin
February 25 2013, 09:12:53 PM
Updated vote tally.

DrumWithMe2012
February 25 2013, 09:39:10 PM
Only a witch would accuse a villager then not even spell his name right.

Seriously:
http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/thumb/0/0a/QWERTY_keyboard.jpg/640px-QWERTY_keyboard.jpg

Yeah yeah I got it. I'm not completely stupid. I was typing during a conversation (always a bad choice) so my apologies for screwing your name up.

Im telling you all, you're going to kill off yet another villager by voting me out. What reason have I given you NOT to trust me here? You can call BS on it all, and most of you have but you'll kick yourselves later when the witches win it because you can't put trust in a person. Cue admitted that he never actually read my PM from Lana. He's not a cheater so do you really think he would legitimately expose another person just to win a game? Unlikely.

LarkinAlpha
February 25 2013, 10:32:09 PM
Well since my vote today doesn't matter anymore, I'm not going to bother.

Of course, it's a win win today. If drum isn't a Witch, then at least half of those who voted for her are, and if she is, we only have 2 left.

Kilabi
February 25 2013, 11:09:06 PM
Well since my vote today doesn't matter anymore, I'm not going to bother.

Of course, it's a win win today. If drum isn't a Witch, then at least half of those who voted for her are, and if she is, we only have 2 left.

You are on the assumption the witches know each other. I nearly got trapped by that when I made my voting excel-sheet.

At least at this point I hope they did not form up already.

LarkinAlpha
February 25 2013, 11:20:25 PM
Well since my vote today doesn't matter anymore, I'm not going to bother.

Of course, it's a win win today. If drum isn't a Witch, then at least half of those who voted for her are, and if she is, we only have 2 left.

You are on the assumption the witches know each other. I nearly got trapped by that when I made my voting excel-sheet.

At least at this point I hope they did not form up already.

It's a "safe" vote since so many are already voting. FYI only 3 people who are not Drum haven't voted for her: Myself, Victoria and You (Kilabi).

I know I'm not, Victoria has professed that (s)he's not, and you're implying you're not, but in reality are also implying that you are.

How suicidal are you Kilabi? I'm going to guess not. So that leaves 6 people and 3 Witches, provided that Drum is NOT a witch. If she is a Witch, well, we're 1 for 2 turns and that's a pretty good ratio.

And if she's not, Cue should be banned from further Mafia games, running or playing.

Me
February 25 2013, 11:31:47 PM
Well since my vote today doesn't matter anymore, I'm not going to bother.

Of course, it's a win win today. If drum isn't a Witch, then at least half of those who voted for her are, and if she is, we only have 2 left.

You are on the assumption the witches know each other. I nearly got trapped by that when I made my voting excel-sheet.

At least at this point I hope they did not form up already.

It's a "safe" vote since so many are already voting. FYI only 3 people who are not Drum haven't voted for her: Myself, Victoria and You (Kilabi).

I know I'm not, Victoria has professed that (s)he's not, and you're implying you're not, but in reality are also implying that you are.

How suicidal are you Kilabi? I'm going to guess not. So that leaves 6 people and 3 Witches, provided that Drum is NOT a witch. If she is a Witch, well, we're 1 for 2 turns and that's a pretty good ratio.

And if she's not, Cue should be banned from further Mafia games, running or playing.

You're missing the fact that witches don't know who are the other witches, which throws off your little theory there.

A good witch play on this vote would have been to not vote for Drum. By doing that they gain some trust in the eyes of some of the village if Drum comes up villager whilst killing a villager in the process (big payoff) or lose a witch who drew too much attention (probably couldn't have been avoided). You yourself said as much with "only 3 people who are not Drum haven't voted for her: Myself, Victoria and You (Kilabi)."

All in all I think this makes you seem more suss for drawing attention to you not voting for Drum.


It's probably too late to swing the vote from Drum but I'm changing to you.

Drum $LarkinAlpha

DrumWithMe2012
February 25 2013, 11:34:35 PM
Well since my vote today doesn't matter anymore, I'm not going to bother.

Of course, it's a win win today. If drum isn't a Witch, then at least half of those who voted for her are, and if she is, we only have 2 left.

You are on the assumption the witches know each other. I nearly got trapped by that when I made my voting excel-sheet.

At least at this point I hope they did not form up already.

It's a "safe" vote since so many are already voting. FYI only 3 people who are not Drum haven't voted for her: Myself, Victoria and You (Kilabi).

I know I'm not, Victoria has professed that (s)he's not, and you're implying you're not, but in reality are also implying that you are.

How suicidal are you Kilabi? I'm going to guess not. So that leaves 6 people and 3 Witches, provided that Drum is NOT a witch. If she is a Witch, well, we're 1 for 2 turns and that's a pretty good ratio.

And if she's not, Cue should be banned from further Mafia games, running or playing.


I think banning Cue from further games is a bit extreme. I disagree with that entirely. He was hanging out with me this weekend and I ran to the grocery. He posted that he read my stuff, but he's a better guy than that. He didn't actually read my PM's, just wanted to annoy me a bit. It's a love-hate thing with the two of us in Mafia games. But banning him from the games? He didn't do anything wrong so I'm thinking that's a bit far.

No, Drum isn't a witch but in about 26 minutes, you'll find that out for yourselves . I'll be interested to see how this game plays out.

DrumWithMe2012
February 25 2013, 11:37:06 PM
qwert LarkinAlpha Thanks for that, Me. Glad to know someone's got h a brain up there.

LarkinAlpha
February 26 2013, 12:03:47 AM
Ahem, $Me is definitely a Witch, and should be voted for next round. Drum, you're not helping your argument considering that I was attempting to save you.

A "safe" vote is easy to spot if you're not a mouth breather, but considering the people who play on FHC, your argument is "valid" $Me.

Anyway, take a look at who advocated for Nicho the first round as well as who voted for Drum in round 2.

pratell
February 26 2013, 12:04:03 AM
Well since my vote today doesn't matter anymore, I'm not going to bother.

Of course, it's a win win today. If drum isn't a Witch, then at least half of those who voted for her are, and if she is, we only have 2 left.

You are on the assumption the witches know each other. I nearly got trapped by that when I made my voting excel-sheet.

At least at this point I hope they did not form up already.

It's a "safe" vote since so many are already voting. FYI only 3 people who are not Drum haven't voted for her: Myself, Victoria and You (Kilabi).

I know I'm not, Victoria has professed that (s)he's not, and you're implying you're not, but in reality are also implying that you are.

How suicidal are you Kilabi? I'm going to guess not. So that leaves 6 people and 3 Witches, provided that Drum is NOT a witch. If she is a Witch, well, we're 1 for 2 turns and that's a pretty good ratio.

And if she's not, Cue should be banned from further Mafia games, running or playing.

You're missing the fact that witches don't know who are the other witches, which throws off your little theory there.

A good witch play on this vote would have been to not vote for Drum. By doing that they gain some trust in the eyes of some of the village if Drum comes up villager whilst killing a villager in the process (big payoff) or lose a witch who drew too much attention (probably couldn't have been avoided). You yourself said as much with "only 3 people who are not Drum haven't voted for her: Myself, Victoria and You (Kilabi)."

All in all I think this makes you seem more suss for drawing attention to you not voting for Drum.


It's probably too late to swing the vote from Drum but I'm changing to you.

Drum $LarkinAlpha

you make a convincing argument. $Drum $Larkin

Lana Torrin
February 26 2013, 12:04:44 AM
Work computer forced an update before it let me log in, so i'll do this post as the cutoff. Doing writeup now.

Edit :

All was not well in the village. Another death proved they had not found the witch. Drastic measure were needed, but the town was divided. Under protest the villagers grabbed Drum, dragging her out in to the street. While some screamed for the madness to stop, other bound and gagged her, they would set her alight. A witch would surly burn brightly this night.

A fire was lit, and drums body was thrown on to it, her screaming caused most to look away until all was silent.

Drum was burnt and found to be a villager.

Qwert
February 26 2013, 12:14:25 AM
Welp, I was just considering changing my vote.

In any case, the thought just occurred to me that the smart selfish play for everyone in this game is to appear just witchy enough, because the obvious witches get lynched, and the obvious villagers get hexed.

Lana Torrin
February 26 2013, 12:17:26 AM
Welp, I was just considering changing my vote.

In any case, the thought just occurred to me that the smart selfish play for everyone in this game is to appear just witchy enough, because the obvious witches get lynched, and the obvious villagers get hexed.

Well you should have got in sooner. It was 5 min over already.

Also notice, no witch death this round.

Me
February 26 2013, 12:18:28 AM
$Larkin again for there reasons outlined here: http://failheap-challenge.com/showthread.php?10827-Mafia-Witch-Hunt&p=721679&viewfull=1#post721679

LarkinAlpha
February 26 2013, 01:12:11 AM
$Me for the obvious reason that I know I'm not a Witch, and he's almost certainly now.

Me, if you're not a witch, and I end up dead this turn, you will be dead next turn, just a thought.

LarkinAlpha
February 26 2013, 01:21:48 AM
Because I can't edit and it just occurred to me. Me's entire argument against myself is that I was making arguments for finding out who was a Witch in a logical manner. Now if we were actually in the 16th century, I could see how Logic would seem magical, but since I am attempting to HELP the village instead of HINDER it, you're going to try and kill me? Your argument hinges on the fact that I am trying to gain the support of the village. I say I don't have to gain the support of the village, only the ire of the witches. As always, I am prepared to die to be proven correct.

Notice I nowhere in that post said that anyone was certainly not a witch. I was just pointing out the most probables. Me, being a semi-intelligent individual, noticed his name was on the "short" list, and instead of trying to argue with me to make the village a better place, proceeded directly to blame. That blame represents a guilty conscience, for who would be feeling guilt except one who knows the truth?

This is not the act of a villager, it is instead the act of one who would curse them, and blight their crops. It is the act of a desperate man, now caught out. Perhaps you should have bargained with the devil for the insight to use power rather than power bereft of forethought.

pratell
February 26 2013, 01:35:40 AM
inb4 there are no witches

Lana Torrin
February 26 2013, 01:54:17 AM
inb4 there are no witches

Yeah im not that bad.. Counts on the front page are correct. I'm enjoying watching this.

LarkinAlpha
February 26 2013, 02:28:49 AM
inb4 there are no witches

Yeah im not that bad.. Counts on the front page are correct. I'm enjoying watching this.

I hope so, that's the best part of running a game. I aim to entertain.

Navigator Six
February 26 2013, 07:30:51 AM
Wait, Drum's not a witch? No! Gah! Hnnng, must stay on target...Drum talked a lot, ergo witches must not. Who's a quiet one around here?

$ctrlchris

ctrlchris
February 26 2013, 08:11:01 AM
Wait, Drum's not a witch? No! Gah! Hnnng, must stay on target...Drum talked a lot, ergo witches must not. Who's a quiet one around here?

$ctrlchris

Ive hardly been quiet, its just I have been asleep when all the posting has been going on, if I had of been up I likely would have swapped to larkin because Me made a better point then the off chance of cue being a massive cunt.

On that note $larkin

Kilabi
February 26 2013, 08:45:41 AM
I think we are rather US-TZ heavy again. I could be posting during my workhours but that means for most others it is like 2AM.

Kilabi
February 26 2013, 08:50:25 AM
I am still not sure about Larkin. Either he tried to taint everyones logic by pretending the witches know each other or he just missed it himself.

As they always say in "who wants to be a millionair": If you talk a lot of nonesense the people in the crowd will still catch on to it, true or not, and the crowd joker is wasted.
Would be a subtle try to push people off the right conclusions while make him look very "villager".

Not sure yet whom to vote today.

duckduck
February 26 2013, 10:06:25 AM
I'm going to vote for Me. He seems to be trying to deflect attention.

Me
February 26 2013, 10:18:42 AM
I'm going to vote for Me. He seems to be trying to deflect attention.

Trying to deflect attention that I never had by making a long post and drawing attention to myself.



If you had a brain you'd be dangerous.

Navigator Six
February 26 2013, 11:38:40 AM
I'm going to vote for Me. He seems to be trying to deflect attention.

Trying to deflect attention that I never had by making a long post and drawing attention to myself.



If you had a brain you'd be dangerous.

Ooh, he's mean too! Are witches mean, generally?

duckduck
February 26 2013, 01:59:25 PM
Ooh, he's mean too! Are witches mean, generally?

Traditionally, yes. Also look out for long noses.

LarkinAlpha
February 26 2013, 04:55:33 PM
I am still not sure about Larkin. Either he tried to taint everyones logic by pretending the witches know each other or he just missed it himself.

As they always say in "who wants to be a millionair": If you talk a lot of nonesense the people in the crowd will still catch on to it, true or not, and the crowd joker is wasted.
Would be a subtle try to push people off the right conclusions while make him look very "villager".

Not sure yet whom to vote today.

Because if I were a witch I'd definitely "Make a mistake" like that. *sigh* I just pointed out an easy vote that anyone could have noticed. And rather than argue with my point, I am apparently a witch. You lot are way to absolute. If people DO NOT SPEAK UP and TALK ABOUT WHO THEY SUSPECT without having to worry about being IMMEDIATELY accused for what amounts to NO REASON, then the witches win. Ergo, the people accusing me are most likely witches.

This will be extremely apparent if/when I die and it's revealed I'm a villager. And considering that I revealed that fairly early again if you were paying attention, it's obvious that they are.

You may not have enjoyed the fact that I kind of took over the last game I played in, but my assumptions there were solid except for one important fact, the number of mafia. So go ahead, test me, you'll find yourselves wanting.

pratell
February 26 2013, 05:03:06 PM
I am still not sure about Larkin. Either he tried to taint everyones logic by pretending the witches know each other or he just missed it himself.

As they always say in "who wants to be a millionair": If you talk a lot of nonesense the people in the crowd will still catch on to it, true or not, and the crowd joker is wasted.
Would be a subtle try to push people off the right conclusions while make him look very "villager".

Not sure yet whom to vote today.

Because if I were a witch I'd definitely "Make a mistake" like that. *sigh* I just pointed out an easy vote that anyone could have noticed. And rather than argue with my point, I am apparently a witch. You lot are way to absolute. If people DO NOT SPEAK UP and TALK ABOUT WHO THEY SUSPECT without having to worry about being IMMEDIATELY accused for what amounts to NO REASON, then the witches win. Ergo, the people accusing me are most likely witches.

This will be extremely apparent if/when I die and it's revealed I'm a villager. And considering that I revealed that fairly early again if you were paying attention, it's obvious that they are.

You may not have enjoyed the fact that I kind of took over the last game I played in, but my assumptions there were solid except for one important fact, the number of mafia. So go ahead, test me, you'll find yourselves wanting.yeah or Kilabi is a witch

Qwert
February 26 2013, 05:18:14 PM
[b]$Victoria[\b]

Abstained on round with no hex.
Complained about no Nicho bandwagon when Nicho was hexed.
Nicho also was one of two voting for Victoria on that turn.
Other than the Nicho post, has been quiet.

Qwert
February 26 2013, 05:19:14 PM
Also, I fail at phone bolding.

Kilabi
February 26 2013, 06:38:12 PM
I am still not sure about Larkin. Either he tried to taint everyones logic by pretending the witches know each other or he just missed it himself.

As they always say in "who wants to be a millionair": If you talk a lot of nonesense the people in the crowd will still catch on to it, true or not, and the crowd joker is wasted.
Would be a subtle try to push people off the right conclusions while make him look very "villager".

Not sure yet whom to vote today.

Because if I were a witch I'd definitely "Make a mistake" like that. *sigh* I just pointed out an easy vote that anyone could have noticed. And rather than argue with my point, I am apparently a witch. You lot are way to absolute. If people DO NOT SPEAK UP and TALK ABOUT WHO THEY SUSPECT without having to worry about being IMMEDIATELY accused for what amounts to NO REASON, then the witches win. Ergo, the people accusing me are most likely witches.

This will be extremely apparent if/when I die and it's revealed I'm a villager. And considering that I revealed that fairly early again if you were paying attention, it's obvious that they are.

You may not have enjoyed the fact that I kind of took over the last game I played in, but my assumptions there were solid except for one important fact, the number of mafia. So go ahead, test me, you'll find yourselves wanting.yeah or Kilabi is a witch

I am now not following the jump to me being a witch?
Larking was right. Discussion here only makes one a witch. Apparently not posting is the best tactic after all. :P

Lana Torrin
February 26 2013, 08:13:27 PM
Votes updated because im awake at 4am.

LarkinAlpha
February 26 2013, 08:53:14 PM
Just to support my own complaints in the OOG thread Me to $Victoria

Kilabi
February 26 2013, 08:59:49 PM
$victoria

Actually the best argument in this thread.

Me
February 26 2013, 09:04:11 PM
Killing off inactives is a reasonable way to go. At least this way we can learn more about the people who actually post.

larkin $victoria

My previous argument still stands though, but another day of watching him doesn't make much difference in the long run.

Lana Torrin
February 26 2013, 09:17:46 PM
updated.

LarkinAlpha
February 26 2013, 10:20:46 PM
Killing off inactives is a reasonable way to go. At least this way we can learn more about the people who actually post.

larkin $victoria

My previous argument still stands though, but another day of watching him doesn't make much difference in the long run.

Your argument is still wrong, but meh, can't hold that against you too much.

pratell
February 26 2013, 10:32:27 PM
i will wait to see if vic offers a defense before voting

pratell
February 26 2013, 11:50:03 PM
$Victoria

Lana Torrin
February 27 2013, 12:05:10 AM
Writeup incoming (before we all have a good fight about the game in to OOG thread)


The town meeting was in chaos. Accusations of whichcraft were flying left and right, but one villager at the back remained silent throughout. As the night continued this absence of anger or judgment slowly started to become noticed. Eventually it became obvious to all, Victoria was watching them.. judging them.

In seconds Victoria had been tied up and had a bag put over his head. A hanging.. A witch would surly expose its self while trying to prevent its own death... A rope was tied to the nearest tree and then tied around Victoria's neck. 4 of the biggest villagers pulled the rope tight and with a shap snap, Victoria went limp.

Victoria was hung and found to be a villager

Qwert
February 27 2013, 12:16:13 AM
Oh well.

Was not expecting Victoria to afk through a lynching too. Chances are Victoria would have been removed soon from inactivity anyway :|

Though, again, no hexings. Interesting.

Lana Torrin
February 27 2013, 12:23:04 AM
Oh well.

Was not expecting Victoria to afk through a lynching too. Chances are Victoria would have been removed soon from inactivity anyway :|

Though, again, no hexings. Interesting.

Kinda happy I didn't have to step in and kill V off.. With only 12 players the village needs as many turns as it can. (Even with the witches also being terrible)

Me
February 27 2013, 12:25:14 AM
Oh well.

Was not expecting Victoria to afk through a lynching too. Chances are Victoria would have been removed soon from inactivity anyway :|

Though, again, no hexings. Interesting.

Kinda happy I didn't have to step in and kill V off.. With only 12 players the village needs as many turns as it can. (Even with the witches also being terrible)

Should do random kill for a draw on the witch vote, more chance of an accidental witch kill and hilarity.

Lana Torrin
February 27 2013, 12:29:08 AM
Oh well.

Was not expecting Victoria to afk through a lynching too. Chances are Victoria would have been removed soon from inactivity anyway :|

Though, again, no hexings. Interesting.

Kinda happy I didn't have to step in and kill V off.. With only 12 players the village needs as many turns as it can. (Even with the witches also being terrible)

Should do random kill for a draw on the witch vote, more chance of an accidental witch kill and hilarity.

Naw it'll be MUCH more fun when they manage it on their own.

pratell
February 27 2013, 01:15:04 AM
8 players

5 villagers

best case, priest knows 2 villagers, 1 and 1, or 2 witches. Worst case is priest peeked Victoria, Nicho, Drum and/or *Cue.

LarkinAlpha
February 27 2013, 01:23:29 AM
$Navigator Six hasn't been arguing for or against, just voting and making pithy jokes. Maybe he's trying to avoid attention?

Navigator Six
February 27 2013, 07:11:13 AM
$Navigator Six hasn't been arguing for or against, just voting and making pithy jokes. Maybe he's trying to avoid attention?

What? Hardly! Have you not read any of my posts? Admittedly the logic was slightly flawed, but that's due to the pressure of trying to refine a system while avoiding being witched.

If you want an argument, here are three:
No witching on turn two also corresponded with cullnean no longer being in the game.
Larkin and Me are both talking an awful lot.
Me is being mean (http://failheap-challenge.com/showthread.php?10827-Mafia-Witch-Hunt&p=722070&viewfull=1#post722070).

The trouble being that now there are many good reasons for suspecting many people! This requires further pondering.

Qwert
February 27 2013, 08:44:41 AM
Tentatively going $chris for a reaction if nothing else. I have :logic: but I'll hold out until I wake up this morning and am not phone posting.

ctrlchris
February 27 2013, 01:01:30 PM
Tentatively going $chris for a reaction if nothing else. I have :logic: but I'll hold out until I wake up this morning and am not phone posting.

RABBLE RABBLE DONT VOTE FOR ME IM A CIV RABBLE RABBLE

The only point I can really defend is same as my vote on day three, my larkin vote was made late-ish at night my time and by the time I was able to check the thread again everyone else had flipped to victoria and the day was over (only this time I was busy doing school stuff all day rather then sleeping in until 12).

ctrlchris
February 27 2013, 01:21:36 PM
I am now going to bed, inb4 I wake up and everyone has voted for me.

duckduck
February 27 2013, 03:46:15 PM
Fellow Goodly People,
As you may, or may not, know, I'm your priest. Since this witchy outbreak I have been praying to God every night. I was hoping that you could see the wicked ones among us, but their evil deception is clearly too strong. I will now have to give more direct guidance, at no small risk to myself.
Kilabi and Me are witches - Kill them. Qwert is a god-fearing villager.
Let's start by killing Me.
I vote to kill Me.

pratell
February 27 2013, 03:49:40 PM
Fellow Goodly People,
As you may, or may not, know, I'm your priest. Since this witchy outbreak I have been praying to God every night. I was hoping that you could see the wicked ones among us, but their evil deception is clearly too strong. I will now have to give more direct guidance, at no small risk to myself.
Kilabi and Me are witches - Kill them. Qwert is a god-fearing villager.
Let's start by killing Me.
I vote to kill Me.

Awesome. $Me.

LarkinAlpha
February 27 2013, 04:43:15 PM
Fellow Goodly People,
As you may, or may not, know, I'm your priest. Since this witchy outbreak I have been praying to God every night. I was hoping that you could see the wicked ones among us, but their evil deception is clearly too strong. I will now have to give more direct guidance, at no small risk to myself.
Kilabi and Me are witches - Kill them. Qwert is a god-fearing villager.
Let's start by killing Me.
I vote to kill Me.

Very nice, those were my other two suspects.

Navigator Six $Me

Qwert
February 27 2013, 05:22:32 PM
Fellow Goodly People,
As you may, or may not, know, I'm your priest. Since this witchy outbreak I have been praying to God every night. I was hoping that you could see the wicked ones among us, but their evil deception is clearly too strong. I will now have to give more direct guidance, at no small risk to myself.
Kilabi and Me are witches - Kill them. Qwert is a god-fearing villager.
Let's start by killing Me.
I vote to kill Me.
Chris

$Me

Navigator Six
February 27 2013, 05:35:56 PM
Well! A witch either way. I hope I'll be able to applaud your noble sacrifice.

$Me

Me
February 27 2013, 08:49:06 PM
Fellow Goodly People,
As you may, or may not, know, I'm your priest. Since this witchy outbreak I have been praying to God every night. I was hoping that you could see the wicked ones among us, but their evil deception is clearly too strong. I will now have to give more direct guidance, at no small risk to myself.
Kilabi and Me are witches - Kill them. Qwert is a god-fearing villager.
Let's start by killing Me.
I vote to kill Me.

Well you're lying about me so $duckduck

ctrlchris
February 27 2013, 11:56:18 PM
Larkin

$Me

Lana Torrin
February 28 2013, 12:13:21 AM
Woken up at 2am so I was late in thismorning.. Doing my writeup now.

Edit: I would be doing my update now, except I'm late for a meeting. It'll be up in about an hour when the meeting is over.

Edit2: The meeting was confused with panic setting in. The village hadn't found any witches yet and time was running out. Accusations had been flying left and right until suddenly Duckduck took the stand, brandishing a cross. "I have preyed for your soles" he said "But some of you have no souls".. He pointed at Me.

Shocked Me stood still. It took a moment for the villagers to react, but they did react first. Grabbing him as tight as they could they gagged him, lest he poison their ears any further. To the river they dragged him, the source of all life. Duckduck himself carried the struggling body of Me in to the water, lifting him with great strength. As he dropped Me in to the water Me stared intently at him with a grin on his face. As he hit the water Me burst in to a brilliant flame which spread over duckduck, consuming him. He screamed and fell in to thew water to try and extinguish the flames, but the water did not quench them.

Me was burnt and found to be a Witch.
Duckduck was burnt by the witches and found to be the priest.

Me
February 28 2013, 12:32:08 AM
Well since I take it I'll die today here's what should happen.

now 5 village vs 3 witch

Tonight I die and as long as the other two witches voted for the obvious choice (duckduck) we'll get 2 kills.

tomorrow 3 village vs 2 witch

witch 2 gets lyched and since they now know each other and can communicate with eachother they get two witch kills which leaves 1 witch 1 village.

gg we win.

LarkinAlpha
February 28 2013, 01:32:21 AM
Well since I take it I'll die today here's what should happen.

now 5 village vs 3 witch

Tonight I die and as long as the other two witches voted for the obvious choice (duckduck) we'll get 2 kills.

tomorrow 3 village vs 2 witch

witch 2 gets lyched and since they now know each other and can communicate with eachother they get two witch kills which leaves 1 witch 1 village.

gg we win.

Are you sure about that? Because if so, then Cue cost us the win tbh.

$Kilabi

Qwert
February 28 2013, 02:52:36 AM
Well since I take it I'll die today here's what should happen.

now 5 village vs 3 witch

Tonight I die and as long as the other two witches voted for the obvious choice (duckduck) we'll get 2 kills.

tomorrow 3 village vs 2 witch

witch 2 gets lyched and since they now know each other and can communicate with eachother they get two witch kills which leaves 1 witch 1 village.

gg we win.

Are you sure about that? Because if so, then Cue cost us the win tbh.

$Kilabi

He's right. However, witches appear to be terrible and only got one this turn.

Now 4v2.

I honestly don't see how we can win. Even if we get it to 4v1 (best case for us), we HAVE TO get the next vote right or its gg, because as I understand it, a single witch can't not have unanimous votes.

Gives us 1 in 5 of getting witch, if not, 1v1 and its gg.



$Kilabi

LarkinAlpha
February 28 2013, 03:02:10 AM
Well since I take it I'll die today here's what should happen.

now 5 village vs 3 witch

Tonight I die and as long as the other two witches voted for the obvious choice (duckduck) we'll get 2 kills.

tomorrow 3 village vs 2 witch

witch 2 gets lyched and since they now know each other and can communicate with eachother they get two witch kills which leaves 1 witch 1 village.

gg we win.

Are you sure about that? Because if so, then Cue cost us the win tbh.

$Kilabi

He's right. However, witches appear to be terrible and only got one this turn.

Now 4v2.

I honestly don't see how we can win. Even if we get it to 4v1 (best case for us), we HAVE TO get the next vote right or its gg, because as I understand it, a single witch can't not have unanimous votes.

Gives us 1 in 5 of getting witch, if not, 1v1 and its gg.



$Kilabi

I checked the OOG thread, and a Single witch only gets one hex a turn.

pratell
February 28 2013, 03:02:52 AM
$Kilabi

I think chris or navigator is the last witch, though i'm only 40/60 on which is which.

(pun intended)

LarkinAlpha
February 28 2013, 03:06:17 AM
We'll have to see who the witches decide to kill this turn. It'll probably be me :ohnoes:

ctrlchris
February 28 2013, 06:02:25 AM
Well this is easy.

$Kilabi

Navigator Six
February 28 2013, 06:49:54 AM
Well this is easy.

$Kilabi

I concur! $KilabiTheWitch

Also, pratell is clearly trying to distract everyone with his awful puns, ergo witch.

Kilabi
February 28 2013, 01:58:41 PM
Sorry for sitting last night out, told Lana already got nightshifted by work and that means no access to internet like during the day.


I am not sure why duckduck called me out on being a witch becauses I am not. I am not sure if he tried to impersonate a priest while being a witch and hit me by accident (as he did not know he was a witch or just sacrificed him) but with him also dying and getting confirmed this theory dies with him.

I guess there are no hidden rules with witch spells or anything to make me appear a witch to him or just falsify the death-result or anything and I have no further idea about what is happening.

Anyway, I am just a villager and while I donīt think this will turn the vote around I hope we can still win this after this vote.

Also: With "Me" dead and "Kilabi" afk last night the vote for the witch could not have come to a full conclusion wich in turn means no burning. Just as food for thought. Something is in the bush here.

ctrlchris
February 28 2013, 02:24:01 PM
Sorry for sitting last night out, told Lana already got nightshifted by work and that means no access to internet like during the day.


I am not sure why duckduck called me out on being a witch becauses I am not. I am not sure if he tried to impersonate a priest while being a witch and hit me by accident (as he did not know he was a witch or just sacrificed him) but with him also dying and getting confirmed this theory dies with him.

I guess there are no hidden rules with witch spells or anything to make me appear a witch to him or just falsify the death-result or anything and I have no further idea about what is happening.

Anyway, I am just a villager and while I donīt think this will turn the vote around I hope we can still win this after this vote.

Also: With "Me" dead and "Kilabi" afk last night the vote for the witch could not have come to a full conclusion wich in turn means no burning. Just as food for thought. Something is in the bush here.

Mate you do realize duckduck is confirmed for the priest and Me was confirmed as a witch in the op, if your not one as well ill eat my hat.

pratell
February 28 2013, 02:27:39 PM
Sorry for sitting last night out, told Lana already got nightshifted by work and that means no access to internet like during the day.


I am not sure why duckduck called me out on being a witch becauses I am not. I am not sure if he tried to impersonate a priest while being a witch and hit me by accident (as he did not know he was a witch or just sacrificed him) but with him also dying and getting confirmed this theory dies with him.

I guess there are no hidden rules with witch spells or anything to make me appear a witch to him or just falsify the death-result or anything and I have no further idea about what is happening.

Anyway, I am just a villager and while I donīt think this will turn the vote around I hope we can still win this after this vote.

Also: With "Me" dead and "Kilabi" afk last night the vote for the witch could not have come to a full conclusion wich in turn means no burning. Just as food for thought. Something is in the bush here.

you are in the bush. and the bush is on fire, and you're burning alive, as it should be.

LarkinAlpha
February 28 2013, 08:02:21 PM
So that's 5 for Kilabi, 1 against, and everyone has voted. Since everyone still alive has been active, I'm going to assume that the Witches have voted too. Come on Lana, I want to see how fucked we are tonight.

Also Me was wrong, it's 4v2 today, and if the witches voted together, it'll be 2v1 tomorrow. So there's still a chance the village can win. The last witch is going to have to be cunning to eek out a win.

pratell
February 28 2013, 08:26:08 PM
So we just have to find the last witch then.

Larkin
Pratell
chris
Navigator

ugh this is going to be ugly

LarkinAlpha
February 28 2013, 09:10:08 PM
Kilabi
Navigator Six
LarkinAlpha
pratell
Qwert - Villager
ctrlchris

I was about to say you forgot Qwert, but he's a confirmed villager (even more so if Kilabi is actually a Witch). So who's likely to die tonight? Might as well pick out two and run with it.

If two people die it's 33% that whoever is left is a Witch. Might have to extend the turn a bit Lana, it's going to get messy.

Lana Torrin
February 28 2013, 10:38:32 PM
On god it's going to finish on a weekend..

On the train. The day is set to finish at 9 am my time because that's when I can get near a computer to do the update.

Talk amongst yourselves....

LarkinAlpha
February 28 2013, 10:41:29 PM
On god it's going to finish on a weekend..

On the train. The day is set to finish at 9 am my time because that's when I can get near a computer to do the update.

Talk amongst yourselves....

Awww... oh well, I'll just have to wait poised on the end of my seat for the update.

Lana Torrin
March 1 2013, 12:07:48 AM
The priest have left notes. There was another witch. Kilabi had been named. The villagers didn't want to risk another drowning, so they decided just to cleanse the town with fire. Kilabi was locked him his house, the villagers decided the whole place was tainted. A fire was lit and the house surrounded to prevent escape. It burned for hours but the villagers saw no sign of Kilabi. After the remains of the building had cooled a burnt out husk was found sitting in a chair, the stretched skin forming what appeared to be a smile on his face.

The villagers retired for the night, confident the witches curse had been lifted from their town.

Qwert was woken by a sound. Someone was outside. He got out of bed and moved slowly to the window. Suddenly there was a crash as Navigator 6 burst through the window. He yelled something incomprehensible before slamming an axe in to the side of Qwerts skull. Navigator stood there for a momnet, loking at what he had done. This was Qwert, not the witch he though he was getting attacked by. How could he have killed his friend? Nothing made sense.. Navigator passed out and was found next to Qwert's body in the morning.

Kilabi was burnt and found to be a witch.
Qwert was killed by the witches and found to be a villager.
Navigator 6 was killed by the witches and found to be a villager.

(As there is now only 1 witch left they will only be getting 1 kill from now on)

Lana Torrin
March 1 2013, 12:12:00 AM
This WILL be the last day. If the witch dies the villagers win. If the villagers kill a villager, in theory the other one should die as well, but if they don't then the witches win anyway. If the village manages to not vote somehow, the witches will get a free kill and will win.

LarkinAlpha
March 1 2013, 12:12:54 AM
So that leaves:

LarkinAlpha
pratell
ctrlchris

I'm so glad I sent Pratell a PM saying that I suspected Chris.

$pratell

Please, defend yourself. This should be good.

ctrlchris
March 1 2013, 03:05:33 AM
So that leaves:

LarkinAlpha
pratell
ctrlchris

I'm so glad I sent Pratell a PM saying that I suspected Chris.

$pratell

Please, defend yourself. This should be good.

Ive got to go with this, the way you jumped down kilabi's throat after his last post makes it seem like you are trying a little too hard to distance yourself from him.

$pratell

pratell
March 1 2013, 03:33:56 AM
So that leaves:

LarkinAlpha
pratell
ctrlchris

I'm so glad I sent Pratell a PM saying that I suspected Chris.

$pratell

Please, defend yourself. This should be good.

Ive got to go with this, the way you jumped down kilabi's throat after his last post makes it seem like you are trying a little too hard to distance yourself from him.

$pratell

correctly predicting a witch after witch backpedals = witch

try again

tbh i don't think larkin is our witch

pratell
March 1 2013, 03:34:17 AM
Sorry for sitting last night out, told Lana already got nightshifted by work and that means no access to internet like during the day.


I am not sure why duckduck called me out on being a witch becauses I am not. I am not sure if he tried to impersonate a priest while being a witch and hit me by accident (as he did not know he was a witch or just sacrificed him) but with him also dying and getting confirmed this theory dies with him.

I guess there are no hidden rules with witch spells or anything to make me appear a witch to him or just falsify the death-result or anything and I have no further idea about what is happening.

Anyway, I am just a villager and while I donīt think this will turn the vote around I hope we can still win this after this vote.

Also: With "Me" dead and "Kilabi" afk last night the vote for the witch could not have come to a full conclusion wich in turn means no burning. Just as food for thought. Something is in the bush here.

you are in the bush. and the bush is on fire, and you're burning alive, as it should be.

lol chris you mean this didn't you

pratell
March 1 2013, 03:43:11 AM
So that leaves:

LarkinAlpha
pratell
ctrlchris

I'm so glad I sent Pratell a PM saying that I suspected Chris.

$pratell

Please, defend yourself. This should be good.




I am still not sure about Larkin. Either he tried to taint everyones logic by pretending the witches know each other or he just missed it himself.

As they always say in "who wants to be a millionair": If you talk a lot of nonesense the people in the crowd will still catch on to it, true or not, and the crowd joker is wasted.
Would be a subtle try to push people off the right conclusions while make him look very "villager".

Not sure yet whom to vote today.

Because if I were a witch I'd definitely "Make a mistake" like that. *sigh* I just pointed out an easy vote that anyone could have noticed. And rather than argue with my point, I am apparently a witch. You lot are way to absolute. If people DO NOT SPEAK UP and TALK ABOUT WHO THEY SUSPECT without having to worry about being IMMEDIATELY accused for what amounts to NO REASON, then the witches win. Ergo, the people accusing me are most likely witches.

This will be extremely apparent if/when I die and it's revealed I'm a villager. And considering that I revealed that fairly early again if you were paying attention, it's obvious that they are.

You may not have enjoyed the fact that I kind of took over the last game I played in, but my assumptions there were solid except for one important fact, the number of mafia. So go ahead, test me, you'll find yourselves wanting.yeah or Kilabi is a witch

here is my defense. i've just reread this thread and the OOG one and tbh i see larkin forgiving nicho after his death, i see larkin harping in every post about how it's so unfair that since he posts he's automatically a witch and now he's literally sent me a PM asking if I think chris or navigator are the witch to which i respond with "yes i agree with both conclusions" and has now aimed his hex at me. man i wonder where he might have looked to see if i had suspected chris and navigator, perhaps this post right here on this page:


$Kilabi

I think chris or navigator is the last witch, though i'm only 40/60 on which is which.

(pun intended)


$Larkin

Navigator Six
March 1 2013, 06:53:00 AM
Well, good luck guys; avenge my death! 8-) I shall avoid kibitzing.

Lana Torrin
March 1 2013, 12:00:22 PM
I was going to give the option to finish this early if everyone is happy, but I forgot to ask when I put the update in. So im going to be mean and finish this one at exactly 1am GMT Saturday. :p

LarkinAlpha
March 1 2013, 04:45:16 PM
Pratell, I have more reasons than that for thinking you a witch. I'm sure that if you addressed them in an appropriate manner that I would reconsider and change my vote, but you failed to do so immediately. Lana, this is probably going to take the whole time simple because of this fact.

If pratell doesn't want to express any more arguments though, you can go ahead and finish the game. Up to him (and Chris if he objects) now.

pratell
March 1 2013, 06:11:22 PM
nope i'm done

gg witches

LarkinAlpha
March 1 2013, 11:15:39 PM
You are a witch, and your first vote yesterday was as follows:
1) Qwert
2) LarkinAlpha

Right around midnight forum time, Kilabi sent you the following PM:


I must have been reading the thread 10 times by now. I think we should vote navigator. Donīt just a feeling.
I am going to change my vote now and go to bed. Sorry to do it like that, hope you read that now. :/

vote 1: qwert
vote 2: navigator

And you, rather than losing the secondary vote, decided to switch with him at the last second. This was a very, very good play by Kilabi, since he was being presented with at least 2 people claiming to be witches.

Unfortunately, my story seemed better than your story, and was backed up by Me's allegations and sudden departure from the exact same allegations. It was also backed up Kilabi's assuming I made the "same mistake" that he did earlier. So he shared with me, at 8pm forum time, that you had also contacted him.

Unfortunately for Kilabi, I was not the other witch. He became suspicious over the course of our conversation, probably when you alerted him that I sent you a PM claiming I suspected Chris at 10:30 forum time. This gave the two of you just 90 minutes to come up with a plan. You could kill me, but if I sent you a PM, I probably sent them to everyone else (including Qwert, and we had a rather nice discussion about what to do if I ended up dead, and he ended up alive) and that would mean you'd probably die no matter what. What if you let my plan go through? Pratell is still found out since that was the whole idea. So that leaves Chris or Navigator, and I'm suspecting Chris so might as well kill Navigator. That should leave me confused enough to throw the final vote and let the witches win.

The problem with that, I haven't seriously suspected Chris from the beginning. And Kilabi suddenly changing his vote when it really doesn't matter? Very suspicious, very suspicious.

The best way to have confused me was to let my plan go through, but without killing Qwert. I would have had some problems with that, but you would have still been the next vote.

I gave you a chance to admit all and try and sway me, and were you an actual villager, you likely would have tried.

Good game either way. And good game to Chris if he's really the last witch, you stayed off my radar completely.

pratell
March 1 2013, 11:29:43 PM
You are a witch, and your first vote yesterday was as follows:
1) Qwert
2) LarkinAlpha

Right around midnight forum time, Kilabi sent you the following PM:


I must have been reading the thread 10 times by now. I think we should vote navigator. Donīt just a feeling.
I am going to change my vote now and go to bed. Sorry to do it like that, hope you read that now. :/

vote 1: qwert
vote 2: navigator

And you, rather than losing the secondary vote, decided to switch with him at the last second. This was a very, very good play by Kilabi, since he was being presented with at least 2 people claiming to be witches.

Unfortunately, my story seemed better than your story, and was backed up by Me's allegations and sudden departure from the exact same allegations. It was also backed up Kilabi's assuming I made the "same mistake" that he did earlier. So he shared with me, at 8pm forum time, that you had also contacted him.

Unfortunately for Kilabi, I was not the other witch. He became suspicious over the course of our conversation, probably when you alerted him that I sent you a PM claiming I suspected Chris at 10:30 forum time. This gave the two of you just 90 minutes to come up with a plan. You could kill me, but if I sent you a PM, I probably sent them to everyone else (including Qwert, and we had a rather nice discussion about what to do if I ended up dead, and he ended up alive) and that would mean you'd probably die no matter what. What if you let my plan go through? Pratell is still found out since that was the whole idea. So that leaves Chris or Navigator, and I'm suspecting Chris so might as well kill Navigator. That should leave me confused enough to throw the final vote and let the witches win.

The problem with that, I haven't seriously suspected Chris from the beginning. And Kilabi suddenly changing his vote when it really doesn't matter? Very suspicious, very suspicious.

The best way to have confused me was to let my plan go through, but without killing Qwert. I would have had some problems with that, but you would have still been the next vote.

I gave you a chance to admit all and try and sway me, and were you an actual villager, you likely would have tried.

Good game either way. And good game to Chris if he's really the last witch, you stayed off my radar completely.

lol wut pm exactly

pratell
March 1 2013, 11:31:42 PM
also wait can you read or are you just making up things? i voted qwert day one and have never voted navigator.

dpidcoe
March 1 2013, 11:43:22 PM
also wait can you read inb4 not being able to read was all part of his clever plan.

pratell
March 1 2013, 11:52:24 PM
also wait can you read inb4 not being able to read was all part of his clever plan.

nah i think larkin is just an idiot, chris is the witch and the fact that he's just piped down so cleverly is convenient. regardless, perhaps Larkin will see the light in the next 8 minutes. Larkin $chris

Lana Torrin
March 2 2013, 12:05:08 AM
Larkin and Chris agreed, Pratell must be the last witch. It was obvious. Larkin struck out first, catching Pratell in the cheek and sending him to the ground. Chris tied him up while he was unconscious and between them, the hoisted him on top of the wood pile. Pratell waited for Larkin to regain consciousness before lighting the wood.

They watched as the fire rose and quickly engulfed Pratell. As it consumed his body Larkin turned to Chris to congratulate him, but stopped short. Chris had a strange grin across his face. Before he know what had happened Chris pushed Larkin backwards and in to the flames. Larkin tried to move to get out again, confused, but for some reason none of his limbs would do has he commanded.. Chris slowly turned and walked away. This village would make a nice home for his friends, once they removed all of the bodies..

Pratell was killed by the village and revealed to be a villager.
Larkin was killed by the last witch.

Good game all, Witches win but it was damn close for the last few turns. (Also, REALLY glad I rechecked the thread before posting that)

Varcaus
March 2 2013, 12:06:07 AM
shocking

ctrlchris
March 2 2013, 12:06:36 AM
http://onebit.us/x/i/xSnLtUBavN.jpg

Me irl

Lana Torrin
March 2 2013, 12:14:05 AM
I'll post the secret voting in a bit. it was pretty damn obvious though that the witches didn't know each other until duckduck said something.

pratell
March 2 2013, 12:17:40 AM
shocking

LarkinAlpha
March 2 2013, 12:19:01 AM
http://onebit.us/x/i/xSnLtUBavN.jpg

Me irl

Well done. I was hoping Pratell would put up a better defense, but meh, I tried.




also wait can you read inb4 not being able to read was all part of his clever plan.

nah i think larkin is just an idiot, chris is the witch and the fact that he's just piped down so cleverly is convenient. regardless, perhaps Larkin will see the light in the next 8 minutes. Larkin $chris

I was busy, sorry. Really wish you'd have said something, but meh, I got played. It happens.

Lana Torrin
March 2 2013, 12:31:19 AM
The Secret voting

For the witches i'll just post them as 1st vote, second vote. Remember the 2nd vote counts for nothing if the first votes don't all match.

Day 1
cullnean (Priest) - Cue
Me (Witch) - Nicho Void, Pratell
Chris (Witch) - Nicho, Me
Kilabi (Witch) - ctrlchris, Me

Day 2
DuckDuck (Priest) - Qwert
Me (Witch) - Kilabi, Qwert
Chris (Witch) - No Votes
Kilabi (Witch) - Victoria Steckersaurus, duckduck

Day 3
DuckDuck (Priest) - Me (First Witch discovered)
Me (Witch) - navigator, pratell
Chris (Witch) - Larkin, Me
Kilabi (Witch) - duckduck, Kilabi

Day 4
DuckDuck (Priest) - Kilabi (Second Witch discovered)
Me (Witch) - duckduck, chris
Chris (Witch) - duckduck, larkin
Kilabi (Witch) - No votes

Day 5
Chris (Witch) - qwert, navigator six (Changed his vote from qwert, pratell)
Kilabi (Witch) - qwert, navigator six

Day 6
Chris (Witch) - Larkin

Edit: Lol I had day 4 backwards and had chris voting for himself.

Lana Torrin
March 2 2013, 12:38:08 AM
Cul quitting on day 1 and HAVING THE PRIEST ROLE scared the crap out of me.. Fortunately I had completely missed duckduck had applied, so he happily stepped it without knowing what culs role was. I desperately tried to cover for the fact I was replacing a key role by doing the whole 'fixed numbers, needs to be balanced' thing.. Given that the witches didn't all work out what I had done until duckduck revealed himself I think it worked well enough.

Also, the witches not voting didn't factor in to my thinking when making the rules, so I treated it the same as I would if the villagers didn't vote (ie, Abstain which will stop the vote from being unanimous).

pratell
March 2 2013, 12:38:52 AM
gg witches, duckduck reveal was excellent. i like your game rules lana.

Me
March 2 2013, 12:48:48 AM
gg guys.


Well played Chris.

ctrlchris
March 2 2013, 01:04:37 AM
Cul quitting on day 1 and HAVING THE PRIEST ROLE scared the crap out of me.. Fortunately I had completely missed duckduck had applied, so he happily stepped it without knowing what culs role was. I desperately tried to cover for the fact I was replacing a key role by doing the whole 'fixed numbers, needs to be balanced' thing.. Given that the witches didn't all work out what I had done until duckduck revealed himself I think it worked well enough.

Also, the witches not voting didn't factor in to my thinking when making the rules, so I treated it the same as I would if the villagers didn't vote (ie, Abstain which will stop the vote from being unanimous).
Hey hey hey. I knew duckduck/cull had a power role, I just didnt know what it was.

e- Did I forget to vote on day 2? welpo.

Lana Torrin
March 2 2013, 01:11:43 AM
Cul quitting on day 1 and HAVING THE PRIEST ROLE scared the crap out of me.. Fortunately I had completely missed duckduck had applied, so he happily stepped it without knowing what culs role was. I desperately tried to cover for the fact I was replacing a key role by doing the whole 'fixed numbers, needs to be balanced' thing.. Given that the witches didn't all work out what I had done until duckduck revealed himself I think it worked well enough.

Also, the witches not voting didn't factor in to my thinking when making the rules, so I treated it the same as I would if the villagers didn't vote (ie, Abstain which will stop the vote from being unanimous).
Hey hey hey. I knew duckduck/cull had a power role, I just didnt know what it was.

e- Did I forget to vote on day 2? welpo.

You slept in. (That's what you said anyway)

ctrlchris
March 2 2013, 01:21:35 AM
Cul quitting on day 1 and HAVING THE PRIEST ROLE scared the crap out of me.. Fortunately I had completely missed duckduck had applied, so he happily stepped it without knowing what culs role was. I desperately tried to cover for the fact I was replacing a key role by doing the whole 'fixed numbers, needs to be balanced' thing.. Given that the witches didn't all work out what I had done until duckduck revealed himself I think it worked well enough.

Also, the witches not voting didn't factor in to my thinking when making the rules, so I treated it the same as I would if the villagers didn't vote (ie, Abstain which will stop the vote from being unanimous).
Hey hey hey. I knew duckduck/cull had a power role, I just didnt know what it was.

e- Did I forget to vote on day 2? welpo.

You slept in. (That's what you said anyway)
That does sound like me.

Lana Torrin
March 2 2013, 01:24:20 AM
ITT: We discover. Witches, heaver than a duckduck.

dpidcoe
March 2 2013, 02:36:35 AM
I was busy, sorry. Really wish you'd have said something, but meh, I got played. It happens. Twice even :)

LarkinAlpha
March 2 2013, 02:50:36 AM
I was busy, sorry. Really wish you'd have said something, but meh, I got played. It happens. Twice even :)

First time was inaccurate information, and I tried my best. This time it was Kilabi doing it just right, and Chris being inconspicuous. I'm assuming that you guys contacted each other the turn before, but you didn't get the second vote matched which threw me. Or that Kilabi is just that suspicious.

I was suspicious (because I always am) and I wanted Pratell to defend himself so I could spot inconsistencies. Meh, the fact that I've gotten played just means that the caliber of player is up there. It's certainly been fun regardless.

Just wish people would talk more, it's way to easy for the village to lose when everyone is being laconic for fear of being voted out.

Me
March 2 2013, 02:57:34 AM
I was busy, sorry. Really wish you'd have said something, but meh, I got played. It happens. Twice even :)

First time was inaccurate information, and I tried my best. This time it was Kilabi doing it just right, and Chris being inconspicuous. I'm assuming that you guys contacted each other the turn before, but you didn't get the second vote matched which threw me. Or that Kilabi is just that suspicious.

I was suspicious (because I always am) and I wanted Pratell to defend himself so I could spot inconsistencies. Meh, the fact that I've gotten played just means that the caliber of player is up there. It's certainly been fun regardless.

Just wish people would talk more, it's way to easy for the village to lose when everyone is being laconic for fear of being voted out.

yep, PMs and quicktopics don't help either. Especially when you infiltrate them :obama:

Only one the village has won so far was the first one when everything but mafia discussions happened in the thread.

Lana Torrin
March 2 2013, 03:35:27 AM
I was busy, sorry. Really wish you'd have said something, but meh, I got played. It happens. Twice even :)

First time was inaccurate information, and I tried my best. This time it was Kilabi doing it just right, and Chris being inconspicuous. I'm assuming that you guys contacted each other the turn before, but you didn't get the second vote matched which threw me. Or that Kilabi is just that suspicious.

I was suspicious (because I always am) and I wanted Pratell to defend himself so I could spot inconsistencies. Meh, the fact that I've gotten played just means that the caliber of player is up there. It's certainly been fun regardless.

Just wish people would talk more, it's way to easy for the village to lose when everyone is being laconic for fear of being voted out.

yep, PMs and quicktopics don't help either. Especially when you infiltrate them :obama:

Only one the village has won so far was the first one when everything but mafia discussions happened in the thread.

I tried to get the village to do this last game and nearly died on the first turn...

dpidcoe
March 2 2013, 03:44:25 AM
I was suspicious (because I always am) and I wanted Pratell to defend himself so I could spot inconsistencies. And this is the kind of strategy that'll cause you to lead the village to defeat every time.

LarkinAlpha
March 2 2013, 04:52:33 AM
I was suspicious (because I always am) and I wanted Pratell to defend himself so I could spot inconsistencies. And this is the kind of strategy that'll cause you to lead the village to defeat every time.

:-P Don't let your head keep you in the room. I'm just trying to get everyone to participate more, and if I have to go over the top every time to do it, I will. If Pratell had described what he did and what he was thinking I would have examined it and then made a decision. Instead he resorted to a simple counter accusation and gave up. *shrug* I'm waiting for a game where I get a role now, been village every time I played so far, and except for this one (for the most part) they've been mafia slanted.

Lana Torrin
March 2 2013, 05:48:17 AM
I was suspicious (because I always am) and I wanted Pratell to defend himself so I could spot inconsistencies. And this is the kind of strategy that'll cause you to lead the village to defeat every time.

:-P Don't let your head keep you in the room. I'm just trying to get everyone to participate more, and if I have to go over the top every time to do it, I will. If Pratell had described what he did and what he was thinking I would have examined it and then made a decision. Instead he resorted to a simple counter accusation and gave up. *shrug* I'm waiting for a game where I get a role now, been village every time I played so far, and except for this one (for the most part) they've been mafia slanted.

You can rest easy in the knowledge that it was completely random. There is no way I would have deliberately picked Me for a witch if the roles would have been picked.. I would likely have been Nicho, one of either Cue or Drum (or whatever your name is now) but not both and then I dont know.. I may have had Me as the priest as that would have been fun.

Kilabi
March 2 2013, 07:49:53 AM
I dont have the full PM history left as my sent mails are gone but I will try to reconstruct it.

After I missed the whole thing with the priest coming out, thank you boss, I had to mails claiming to be the last witch. Chris and larkin. I honestly had no idea who was the true witch so I tried to stay passive and see who they want to vote for.
Unfortunately they wanted to vote each other which puts me in a position to decide who I trust to get the second kill.

Only way to get the second kill for sure was to make "them" vote someone else. The real witch had to know to vote with me and the wrong witch had to get some wrong info to get fooled and led away from each other, so whoever is the real witch gets a headstart for the last day.

So the plan was to last second switch to navigator and at some point claim pratell is also claiming witch by PM. Navigator would hereby be killed, the real witch would not think anything of it because obviously he knows he is the real witch while the impersonator could be following the lead, wrongly, and think pratell is the other witch.

I read through the thread again and check whos posting is easier to copy in a fake PM. Went with pratell as he does not use capitalization because that is a nice giveaway and a difference to my posting.










I'm the other Witch. I'm voting for chris unless you have a much better idea.

BTW nice deflection with the spreadsheet thing. But boo on you trying to call me out. :-P


Think the only confirmed one needs to go first to night. So vote 1: qwert

Not sure on the second one. Thoughts?

How about 1: qwert and 2: chris?

Okay.

So vote 1: qwert
and
vote 2: chris

Hope you can make to the end now but with the priest gone and the 2 kills today you have a good chance.

In the afternoon I got a PM by Pratell claiming to be the other witch. Bit late I think but A+ for effort.

Nice. Who'd he want to vote for? Curious if my actions in the thread have been working.



horrible try to get out m8
i am the last after today, make it a double kill tonight

qwert and larkin imho

You, that is what gave it away for me.

Nice, well that's a win then. Don't crow in the thread too much.

I must have been reading the thread 10 times by now. I think we should vote navigator. Donīt just a feeling.
I am going to change my vote now and go to bed. Sorry to do it like that, hope you read that now. :/

vote 1: qwert
vote 2: navigator

Sure I can do that.


I do not have the PMs with chris anymore. But they went pretty much the same but he was afkish I guess he never asked something back.
Went like:

IAMA witch ask me anything, and vote larkin
-hi, lol pratell also claimed witch
-mate vote navigator
ok

Was a nice game. For once I had a role that mattered. Fuck coroner in the last game. :P
GG

ctrlchris
March 2 2013, 08:12:06 AM
I dont have the full PM history left as my sent mails are gone but I will try to reconstruct it.

After I missed the whole thing with the priest coming out, thank you boss, I had to mails claiming to be the last witch. Chris and larkin. I honestly had no idea who was the true witch so I tried to stay passive and see who they want to vote for.
Unfortunately they wanted to vote each other which puts me in a position to decide who I trust to get the second kill.

Only way to get the second kill for sure was to make "them" vote someone else. The real witch had to know to vote with me and the wrong witch had to get some wrong info to get fooled and led away from each other, so whoever is the real witch gets a headstart for the last day.

So the plan was to last second switch to navigator and at some point claim pratell is also claiming witch by PM. Navigator would hereby be killed, the real witch would not think anything of it because obviously he knows he is the real witch while the impersonator could be following the lead, wrongly, and think pratell is the other witch.

I read through the thread again and check whos posting is easier to copy in a fake PM. Went with pratell as he does not use capitalization because that is a nice giveaway and a difference to my posting.










I'm the other Witch. I'm voting for chris unless you have a much better idea.

BTW nice deflection with the spreadsheet thing. But boo on you trying to call me out. :-P


Think the only confirmed one needs to go first to night. So vote 1: qwert

Not sure on the second one. Thoughts?

How about 1: qwert and 2: chris?

Okay.

So vote 1: qwert
and
vote 2: chris

Hope you can make to the end now but with the priest gone and the 2 kills today you have a good chance.

In the afternoon I got a PM by Pratell claiming to be the other witch. Bit late I think but A+ for effort.

Nice. Who'd he want to vote for? Curious if my actions in the thread have been working.



horrible try to get out m8
i am the last after today, make it a double kill tonight

qwert and larkin imho

You, that is what gave it away for me.

Nice, well that's a win then. Don't crow in the thread too much.

I must have been reading the thread 10 times by now. I think we should vote navigator. Donīt just a feeling.
I am going to change my vote now and go to bed. Sorry to do it like that, hope you read that now. :/

vote 1: qwert
vote 2: navigator

Sure I can do that.


I do not have the PMs with chris anymore. But they went pretty much the same but he was afkish I guess he never asked something back.
Went like:

IAMA witch ask me anything, and vote larkin
-hi, lol pratell also claimed witch
-mate vote navigator
ok

Was a nice game. For once I had a role that mattered. Fuck coroner in the last game. :P
GG

In that 12 (or so) hour period from when I first pm'd you to you dying I was asleep and I woke up to about 8 pm's from you/larkin/navigator and I think someone else.

so so many pm's

Kilabi
March 2 2013, 08:50:01 AM
Haha.

LarkinAlpha
March 2 2013, 10:01:06 AM
Like I said in my response PM, it was well done Kilabi. I knew the real witch was going to contact you, what I should have counted on was you not believing me and lying. That last bit should have tipped me off. Had I been around today to think about it, I might have but meh, I wasn't and didn't so it's a moot point.

And for the record Lana, IMO, this was the best balanced game so far. Very enjoyable even if it induced some burn out near the end.

Navigator Six
March 2 2013, 10:08:08 AM
It's quite likely that I got myself killed on the last turn, as the first thing I did when Lark sent me his PM was forward it to Qwert and chris. 8-) Good work on being the only person to PM me the entire game.

edit: 747 posts!

http://www.boeing.com/commercial/747family/images/747-8i_inflight_580.jpg

duckduck
March 2 2013, 10:13:58 AM
Great game, thanks Lana.

It was my first game, so being the priest was a bit demanding. I need to be a bit more subtle next time and publicly outing Qwert as a good guy was dumb, but we at least had a chance of winning in the end.

LarkinAlpha
March 2 2013, 10:44:44 AM
It's quite likely that I got myself killed on the last turn, as the first thing I did when Lark sent me his PM was forward it to Qwert and chris. 8-) Good work on being the only person to PM me the entire game.

edit: 747 posts!

http://www.boeing.com/commercial/747family/images/747-8i_inflight_580.jpg

No harm no foul there, I sent Chris the exact same message I sent you, only with your name instead of his. And I sent a much more detailed message to Qwert, just in case.

In hindsight, I should have voted the exact way I pointed out to you.

pratell
March 2 2013, 01:35:31 PM
[spoiler]I dont have the full PM history left as my sent mails are gone but I will try to reconstruct it.

After I missed the whole thing with the priest coming out, thank you boss, I had to mails claiming to be the last witch. Chris and larkin. I honestly had no idea who was the true witch so I tried to stay passive and see who they want to vote for.
Unfortunately they wanted to vote each other which puts me in a position to decide who I trust to get the second kill.

Only way to get the second kill for sure was to make "them" vote someone else. The real witch had to know to vote with me and the wrong witch had to get some wrong info to get fooled and led away from each other, so whoever is the real witch gets a headstart for the last day.

So the plan was to last second switch to navigator and at some point claim pratell is also claiming witch by PM. Navigator would hereby be killed, the real witch would not think anything of it because obviously he knows he is the real witch while the impersonator could be following the lead, wrongly, and think pratell is the other witch.

I read through the thread again and check whos posting is easier to copy in a fake PM. Went with pratell as he does not use capitalization because that is a nice giveaway and a difference to my posting.










I'm the other Witch. I'm voting for chris unless you have a much better idea.

BTW nice deflection with the spreadsheet thing. But boo on you trying to call me out. :-P


Think the only confirmed one needs to go first to night. So vote 1: qwert

Not sure on the second one. Thoughts?

How about 1: qwert and 2: chris?

Okay.

So vote 1: qwert
and
vote 2: chris

Hope you can make to the end now but with the priest gone and the 2 kills today you have a good chance.

In the afternoon I got a PM by Pratell claiming to be the other witch. Bit late I think but A+ for effort.

Nice. Who'd he want to vote for? Curious if my actions in the thread have been working.



horrible try to get out m8
i am the last after today, make it a double kill tonight

qwert and larkin imho

You, that is what gave it away for me.

Nice, well that's a win then. Don't crow in the thread too much.

I must have been reading the thread 10 times by now. I think we should vote navigator. Donīt just a feeling.
I am going to change my vote now and go to bed. Sorry to do it like that, hope you read that now. :/

vote 1: qwert
vote 2: navigator

Sure I can do that.


I do not have the PMs with chris anymore. But they went pretty much the same but he was afkish I guess he never asked something back.
Went like:

IAMA witch ask me anything, and vote larkin
-hi, lol pratell also claimed witch
-mate vote navigator
ok

Was a nice game. For once I had a role that mattered. Fuck coroner in the last game. :P
GG[spoiler]

big ups

ctrlchris
March 2 2013, 01:37:04 PM
It's quite likely that I got myself killed on the last turn, as the first thing I did when Lark sent me his PM was forward it to Qwert and chris. 8-) Good work on being the only person to PM me the entire game.

edit: 747 posts!

http://www.boeing.com/commercial/747family/images/747-8i_inflight_580.jpg

No harm no foul there, I sent Chris the exact same message I sent you, only with your name instead of his. And I sent a much more detailed message to Qwert, just in case.

In hindsight, I should have voted the exact way I pointed out to you.

I guessed the message forwarded by nav6 was legit being from you larkin because they were exactly the same just named changed

LarkinAlpha
March 2 2013, 10:53:43 PM
So.... next game? If no one else wants to run one I'm willing to run a Simple, sherrif + mafia game.

Lana Torrin
March 2 2013, 11:14:25 PM
So.... next game? If no one else wants to run one I'm willing to run a Simple, sherrif + mafia game.

i think we are burnt out for a bit.. Give it a few weeks.

pratell
March 3 2013, 02:54:36 AM
yea my butt hurts, let's do a st. paddy's game.

Qwert
March 3 2013, 03:46:22 AM
I say the next one should be totally vanilla. 1-2 docs, 2 sheriff, no Don.

Toxic
March 3 2013, 11:50:30 AM
Chris is a bitch.. I mean, witch :-P

Nailed it!

:obama:

Flightly
March 4 2013, 11:57:54 PM
I'm in for another game whenever, but I agree, it should be a simple one.

Lana Torrin
March 5 2013, 01:07:48 AM
I'm in for another game whenever, but I agree, it should be a simple one.

I liked running this one, but god damn it was hard not to laugh at everyone EVERY round. I'm happy to run another one but it'll need to wait for a few weeks.