PDA

View Full Version : [MAFIA]Heap Challenge Round 3: OOG



Pages : [1] 2

Cue1*
February 2 2013, 06:07:52 AM
Looks like round two is winding down. I will be your moderator this time around. I'll be incorporating what I liked from Steph's run and Spasm's run, as well as some cool stuff of my own.

Roles:

Sheriff- Village. Investigates one person each day to learn their guilt(Guilty/Innocent). 10% failure rate(I role a d10. A '1' is a failure, everything else is a pass).
Nut- Village. Thinks he's sheriff but receives bad info or failures for investigations.
Doctor- Village. Protects one person each day from mafia attacks. Can protect self, 30% chance of dieing when successfully protecting someone.
Coroner- Village. As long as a coroner is alive, the alignment(Mafia/Village/Neutral) of everyone who dies as they die. Can investigate one dead person to learn their role.
Lawyer- Village. Redirects the lynch once per game from himself to someone else. Appears guilty to the sheriff.
Vigilante- Village. Can kill a player twice per game, appears guilty of the sheriff.
Village Idiot- Neutral. Wins the game(separately from village or mafia) if he's lynched by the village.
Federal Cop- Neutral. Investigates one person each day to learn if they're the turncoat. Wins the game(separately from village or mafia) if he finds the turncoat. If killed, takes everyone involved in his death with him(so all the villagers who voted for him or the mafia who killed him).
Turncoat- Neutral. Starts as a villager, can swap to mafia(but not back) before day three passes. If he hasn't swapped by day three, becomes a standard villager.
Don- Mafia. head of the mafia, decides who dies each night, appears innocent to the sheriff.


Rules:

-Votes should be bold, standard size and text.
-No screenshots. Absolutely none.
-Bold your lynch votes.
-No editing posts. Editing for spelling or format within a few seconds of posting is kinda acceptable, but try not to. To change your lynch vote, post a new post, strike out your previous vote, then bold your new vote.
-At the end of each day(every 24 hours) I will post everyone who died, what their alignment was(as long as a coroner is still alive), and how they were killed.
-The objective is to win, not to survive. Dead players share in their teams victory.
-Lying about your role is seriously encouraged, the hilarity of the results are on you though.
-If the vote for a lynch is tied, no one will be lynched.
-Abstaining is a vote to not lynch anyone. If the majority vote is for abstaining, then there will be no lynch.


First two slots are reserved for the previous moderators, unless they don't want to play.
Signups:
-Steph
-Spasm
-DrumWithMe
-Kilabi
-EchoEpsilon23
-Lana Torrin
-Inora Aknaria
-Cullean
-Tyrehl
-Nicho Void
-Varcaus
-LordsServant
-Devec
-Pratell
-Wrack
-crtlchris
-Victoria Steckersaurus
-Pacefalm
-Me
-Qwert
-Bentguru

Kilabi
February 2 2013, 06:18:28 AM
Signup. o/

Donīt you think the federal cop could break the game?

If we play with don only the don would die if the mafia targets him but if we lynch half the players will be gone and depending on mafia participation the game could be over at this point. ^^

EchoEpsilon23
February 2 2013, 06:19:22 AM
I'll sign up.

Lana Torrin
February 2 2013, 07:50:13 AM
May as well sign up for this one. It looked like fun.

Edit: Also jumping on the 'Fed could end it all' bandwaggon. Also, can day 1 be days actual days?

Kanv
February 2 2013, 08:45:38 AM
I'll sit this round out unless you need more numbers.

cullnean
February 2 2013, 02:37:29 PM
sigining up

Tyrehl
February 2 2013, 02:38:56 PM
Memememe!

Finally, in time :D


Edit: Checked the first thread and the rules/wiki page, the only questions I have left are the following:
> How does investigating (sheriff) / protecting someone (doc) work? If we have the respective roles do we send a PM to the moderator? It would be pretty dumb to ask this once the game starts (would reveal a possible role etc), better safe than sorry.
> How not to be bad at :mafia: / :regular citizen:? This is my first round :( dont want to go down on night 1

Actually that's all.

Nicho Void
February 2 2013, 03:28:14 PM
Signing up.

If the majority abstain, no one is lynched. Remember this before we have 10 pages of graphs again.

Cue1*
February 2 2013, 03:33:03 PM
Donīt you think the federal cop could break the game?

Maybe. It's a trial run on a new role, one I expect fhc will make amazingly funny. Maybe he only kills half if lynched by the village.


How does investigating (sheriff) / protecting someone (doc) work? If we have the respective roles do we send a PM to the moderator? It would be pretty dumb to ask this once the game starts (would reveal a possible role etc), better safe than sorry.
> How not to be bad at :mafia: / :regular citizen:? This is my first round :( dont want to go down on night 1

Anyone with roles sends me a PM with their choices. You can also ask questions by PM should you feel asking it would give you away.

Keep your head down? It becomes pretty clear once you start.
Also, can day 1 be days actual days?

Did everyone like the 48 hour day 1? I didn't actually, but I have been known to be weird.

the thing from the buzz buzz

Victoria Steckersaurus
February 2 2013, 03:45:53 PM
I'm debating signing up, it might be fun to sit back and watch this one.

I assume 'normal citizen' and 'normal mafia' are included, that is just a list of special roles.

Will we know numbers of each or will it be a mystery?

Varcaus
February 2 2013, 03:59:09 PM
I swear I posted here but sign me up. What happened to 40k?

cullnean
February 2 2013, 04:59:01 PM
I swear I posted here but sign me up. What happened to 40k?

Yeah, I wants to be genestealer killing some one err night that both sides have to kill

Tapatalk

LarkinAlpha
February 2 2013, 05:04:06 PM
I'm going to skip this one, unless there isn't enough sign ups (doubtful)


I swear I posted here but sign me up. What happened to 40k?

I'll run it if there's enough interest, but I'm going to rework the rules a bit more. And wait till this one is over.

Varcaus
February 2 2013, 05:06:38 PM
I'm going to skip this one, unless there isn't enough sign ups (doubtful)


I swear I posted here but sign me up. What happened to 40k?

I'll run it if there's enough interest, but I'm going to rework the rules a bit more. And wait till this one is over.Awesome

Bentguru
February 2 2013, 05:28:03 PM
In

Steph
February 2 2013, 05:51:39 PM
I respectfully request an m/P ratio not to exceed .25

Cue1*
February 2 2013, 05:52:37 PM
Will we know numbers of each or will it be a mystery?

Mystery.


What happened to 40k?

I'm not a 40k guy. Sorry. That said, this game will be themed. :D

the thing from the buzz buzz

Qwert
February 2 2013, 05:54:33 PM
In please

Varcaus
February 2 2013, 06:01:41 PM
Will we know numbers of each or will it be a mystery?

Mystery.


What happened to 40k?

I'm not a 40k guy. Sorry. That said, this game will be themed. :D

the thing from the buzz buzzHERESY! ;) Any hints to the theme?

LordsServant
February 2 2013, 06:06:04 PM
Sign me up, this looks fun.

Devec
February 2 2013, 06:13:20 PM
Signing in.

May I suggest on the rule of voting that votes would have to be done like this:


Mafia scum


The list function can be found in the advanced post section or just through the following commands:

[.LIST]
[.*][.B]Mafia scum[./B]
[./LIST]

Qwert
February 2 2013, 06:23:45 PM
So what specifically will the nut get when he investigates?

"Nut- Village. Thinks he's sheriff but receives bad info or failures for investigations."

Will it be totally random? exactly opposite with wrong roles? 90% fail?

dpidcoe
February 2 2013, 07:07:19 PM
Sign me up, this looks fun.
day1 bandwagon spotted

Varcaus
February 2 2013, 07:10:52 PM
Sign me up, this looks fun.
day1 bandwagon spotted

Nicho will provide more butthurt again imo

cullnean
February 2 2013, 07:44:41 PM
Sign me up, this looks fun.
day1 bandwagon spotted

Nicho will provide more butthurt again imo

Theme?

Any thing remotely scfi will have jizz dripping g down the walls with us tbh

Tapatalk

pratell
February 2 2013, 07:54:23 PM
i'm in!

pratell
February 2 2013, 07:58:36 PM
Signing in.

May I suggest on the rule of voting that votes would have to be done like this:


Mafia scum


The list function can be found in the advanced post section or just through the following commands:

[.LIST]
[.*][.B]Mafia scum[./B]
[./LIST]sounds like a pain in the balls on a phone, why can't we just do $vote

LarkinAlpha
February 2 2013, 08:10:03 PM
Signing in.

May I suggest on the rule of voting that votes would have to be done like this:


Mafia scum


The list function can be found in the advanced post section or just through the following commands:

[.LIST]
[.*][.B]Mafia scum[./B]
[./LIST]sounds like a pain in the balls on a phone, why can't we just do $vote

$$vote might be better, for quicker searches.

Nicho Void
February 2 2013, 08:16:10 PM
Sign me up, this looks fun.
day1 bandwagon spotted

Nicho will provide more butthurt again imo
Mate, I'm lynching you regardless of role. Only smart play.

Steph
February 2 2013, 08:39:23 PM
I believe someone suggested recruiting Barth into this...

Varcaus
February 2 2013, 08:54:09 PM
Sign me up, this looks fun.
day1 bandwagon spotted

Nicho will provide more butthurt again imo
Mate, I'm lynching you regardless of role. Only smart play.You like killing citizens so nbs really. So butthurt

pratell
February 2 2013, 09:02:16 PM
Signing in.

May I suggest on the rule of voting that votes would have to be done like this:


Mafia scum


The list function can be found in the advanced post section or just through the following commands:

[.LIST]
[.*][.B]Mafia scum[./B]
[./LIST]sounds like a pain in the balls on a phone, why can't we just do $vote

$$vote might be better, for quicker searches.

Why is the double dollar faster?

spasm
February 2 2013, 09:19:11 PM
Why is the double dollar faster?

ctrl f

dpidcoe
February 2 2013, 09:20:47 PM
Why is the double dollar faster?

ctrl f

ctrl f $ is faster to type than ctrl f $$ :|

LarkinAlpha
February 2 2013, 09:23:04 PM
Signing in.

May I suggest on the rule of voting that votes would have to be done like this:


Mafia scum


The list function can be found in the advanced post section or just through the following commands:

[.LIST]
[.*][.B]Mafia scum[./B]
[./LIST]sounds like a pain in the balls on a phone, why can't we just do $vote

$$vote might be better, for quicker searches.

Why is the double dollar faster?

Just in case someone, for some reason, types a regular Dollar in the text.

pratell
February 2 2013, 09:27:35 PM
Signing in.

May I suggest on the rule of voting that votes would have to be done like this:


Mafia scum


The list function can be found in the advanced post section or just through the following commands:

[.LIST]
[.*][.B]Mafia scum[./B]
[./LIST]sounds like a pain in the balls on a phone, why can't we just do $vote

$$vote might be better, for quicker searches.

Why is the double dollar faster?

Just in case someone, for some reason, types a regular Dollar in the text.

are you an engineer

Cue1*
February 2 2013, 09:47:57 PM
Signup list updated.


So what specifically will the nut get when he investigates?

"Nut- Village. Thinks he's sheriff but receives bad info or failures for investigations."

Will it be totally random? exactly opposite with wrong roles? 90% fail?

Generally will be opposite. Failure and potentially correct just often enough to make the player believe he IS a sheriff.


Any hints to the theme?

Have been considering a few different ones. Something I do a bit different is I tend to up the story telling. The end of the day won't be "Varcaus the villager was lynched, Steph the neutral was gunned down". I'll likely have a short paragraph of more details into their death. Currently, I'm leading towards a mental hospital setting(players don't die, they are cured and released back into the population), but could be convinced to try something scifi as well. I suspect a Star Trek setting during the Dominion War would be pretty easy to make fit.

:Tabletz:

Qwert
February 2 2013, 09:57:52 PM
Battlestar.

Mafia are cylons. Nut is Baltar.


In please

Also, i want to join.

cullnean
February 2 2013, 10:04:40 PM
Signing in.

May I suggest on the rule of voting that votes would have to be done like this:


Mafia scum


The list function can be found in the advanced post section or just through the following commands:

[.LIST]
[.*][.B]Mafia scum[./B]
[./LIST]sounds like a pain in the balls on a phone, why can't we just do $vote

$$vote might be better, for quicker searches.

Why is the double dollar faster?

Just in case someone, for some reason, types a regular Dollar in the text.

are you an engineer

Nerds

Tapatalk

Wrack
February 2 2013, 10:45:09 PM
I'll give this a go, this time around.

ctrlchris
February 2 2013, 10:47:58 PM
Yeah ok.

Ill be spewin if I get killed first again tho~

Victoria Steckersaurus
February 2 2013, 11:22:25 PM
Yeah ok.

Ill be spewin if I get killed first again tho~

You know what that means, right?

If you're not dead first night, I'm assuming you're mafia.

Also, I'd like to be in.

LordsServant
February 2 2013, 11:22:55 PM
-LifesServant
-
-
-
-
-
-

Wat.

Wat.

Wat.

WAT?

Pacefalm
February 2 2013, 11:27:53 PM
Sign me up

Me
February 2 2013, 11:38:25 PM
I'll play.

Cue1*
February 3 2013, 12:29:09 AM
Alright, first post updated. One slot left I think. Roles will go out as soon as the last slot is filled and I notice. Game will start after that since round 2 is now over.

Making lords federal cop and victoria village idiot so you cunts don't day one bandwagon them and so I can feel vindicated for victoria playing me like a violin last game. :p

the thing from the buzz buzz

TheManFromDelmonte
February 3 2013, 12:38:30 AM
oh man now the mod is metagaming :D

dpidcoe
February 3 2013, 12:52:18 AM
tbh it should be a rule that someone must be lynched on day1.

Steph
February 3 2013, 12:52:33 AM
I'd be lying if I said I never handpicked a Village Idiot to discourage day-1 bandwagoning the same guy in other games I've moderated.

One dude on a GameFAQs forum won three or four games in a row that way before people caught on.

inora aknaria
February 3 2013, 12:53:00 AM
I would like to try again.

Varcaus
February 3 2013, 12:53:02 AM
tbh it should be a rule that someone must be lynched on day1.

+1

Pacefalm
February 3 2013, 12:54:22 AM
-If the vote for a lynch is tied, no one will be lynched.
This already means that my :math: from previous game is invalidated anyway. In this case lynching is always better than abstaining.

Qwert
February 3 2013, 12:55:05 AM
Alright, first post updated. One slot left I think. Roles will go out as soon as the last slot is filled and I notice. Game will start after that since round 2 is now over.

Making lords federal cop and victoria village idiot so you cunts don't day one bandwagon them and so I can feel vindicated for victoria playing me like a violin last game. :p

the thing from the buzz buzz

I really do want in.

Me
February 3 2013, 12:57:56 AM
-If the vote for a lynch is tied, no one will be lynched.
This already means that my :math: from previous game is invalidated anyway. In this case lynching is always better than abstaining.

I don't know about that since the mafia have enough of a voting block to push it away from them. Especially if we have 1/3 mafia like last time.

Sure they'll play it like you did last time and not all vote the same, but 2 or 3 would still be enough to influence things.

Cue1*
February 3 2013, 01:00:00 AM
Alright, first post updated. One slot left I think. Roles will go out as soon as the last slot is filled and I notice. Game will start after that since round 2 is now over.

Making lords federal cop and victoria village idiot so you cunts don't day one bandwagon them and so I can feel vindicated for victoria playing me like a violin last game. :p

the thing from the buzz buzz

I really do want in.

so you do. Filled. Working roles now. Drum has bribed me with a blowjob for a role. Not sure if i'm going to give in or not. Going away to do roles though, so she won't see.

the thing from the buzz buzz

Pacefalm
February 3 2013, 01:00:19 AM
-If the vote for a lynch is tied, no one will be lynched.
This already means that my :math: from previous game is invalidated anyway. In this case lynching is always better than abstaining.

I don't know about that since the mafia have enough of a voting block to push it away from them. Especially if we have 1/3 mafia like last time.

Sure they'll play it like you did last time and not all vote the same, but 2 or 3 would still be enough to influence things.

True, my model used completely random lynches every night which is not 100% accurate.

@Cue, if the mafia attack the Federal Cop, are they all killed or just the Don?

spasm
February 3 2013, 01:01:19 AM
I prefered money instead of blowjobs for my bribes.

But dpidcoe might suck a mean dick for all I know.


damn

ctrlchris
February 3 2013, 01:01:58 AM
So many power roles.

Pacefalm
February 3 2013, 01:02:46 AM
Also it seems I have to become more active in IRC since that is where all the action is.

Me
February 3 2013, 01:03:18 AM
So much potential for hilarity in the Fed role.

Cue1*
February 3 2013, 01:10:57 AM
@Cue, if the mafia attack the Federal Cop, are they all killed or just the Don?

Low mafia numbers so one mafia will die with the federal cop. Also decided half of the village who voted for the fed at random will die with him. Kill a fed and the whole FBI will tear your town up. :D

the thing from the buzz buzz

EchoEpsilon23
February 3 2013, 01:10:59 AM
Can we do this after the American superbowl? Or at least make the first day 48 hours?

Cue1*
February 3 2013, 01:12:02 AM
Can we do this after the American superbowl? Or at least make the first day 48 hours?

I have a superbowl party to go to, so yes, 48 hour first day I guess.

the thing from the buzz buzz

Me
February 3 2013, 01:13:17 AM
@Cue, if the mafia attack the Federal Cop, are they all killed or just the Don?

Low mafia numbers so one mafia will die with the federal cop. Also decided half of the village who voted for the fed at random will die with him. Kill a fed and the whole FBI will tear your town up. :D

the thing from the buzz buzz

Awww, I was hoping for a massive day one bandwagon on the G-man leaving only a couple of players for day 2.

LarkinAlpha
February 3 2013, 01:25:10 AM
@Cue, if the mafia attack the Federal Cop, are they all killed or just the Don?

Low mafia numbers so one mafia will die with the federal cop. Also decided half of the village who voted for the fed at random will die with him. Kill a fed and the whole FBI will tear your town up. :D

the thing from the buzz buzz

This will lead to hilarity, since the Mafia count as villagers for this.

pratell
February 3 2013, 01:43:11 AM
i got a pm! i got a pm!

oh god i can't handle this

Me
February 3 2013, 01:44:28 AM
i got a pm! i got a pm!

oh god i can't handle this

The anticipation :ohnoes:

pratell
February 3 2013, 01:50:36 AM
http://i.imgur.com/3LSFgA4.gif

Lana Torrin
February 3 2013, 01:51:50 AM
So first day is 48 hours then? Sweeeeeet..

cullnean
February 3 2013, 01:55:52 AM
i got a pm! i got a pm!

oh god i can't handle this

The anticipation :ohnoes:

Received and understood

Tapatalk

Cue1*
February 3 2013, 01:57:33 AM
Ok, think I got everyone, if you didn't get a pm from me and signed up, send me one.

the thing from the buzz buzz

EchoEpsilon23
February 3 2013, 01:59:55 AM
WOW, thanks, THANK YOU Cue1 for the role, oh man, I really wanted that role to begin with. Oh, the stuff I will be able to pull! HEHEHE

cullnean
February 3 2013, 02:00:33 AM
WOW, thanks, THANK YOU Cue1 for the role, oh man, I really wanted that role to begin with. Oh, the stuff I will be able to pull! HEHEHE

Villager spotted

Tapatalk

Bentguru
February 3 2013, 02:01:52 AM
Fucking Cue, I get a PM and get all excited but NOOOOOOOOOOOOOO, not mafia.

Fuck you cue

cullnean
February 3 2013, 02:02:39 AM
Fucking Cue, I get a PM and get all excited but NOOOOOOOOOOOOOO, not mafia.

Fuck you cue

Mafia spotted

Tapatalk

Me
February 3 2013, 02:05:20 AM
Fucking Cue, I get a PM and get all excited but NOOOOOOOOOOOOOO, not mafia.

Fuck you cue

Mafia spotted

Tapatalk

Spotter spotted.

Qwert
February 3 2013, 02:06:00 AM
With the number of roles/people, we either have one doctor and one sheriff, or everyone has a power role.

cullnean
February 3 2013, 02:06:03 AM
Fucking Cue, I get a PM and get all excited but NOOOOOOOOOOOOOO, not mafia.

Fuck you cue

Mafia spotted

Tapatalk

Spotter spotted.

Shit I have been spotted

Tapatalk

EchoEpsilon23
February 3 2013, 02:06:36 AM
WOW, thanks, THANK YOU Cue1 for the role, oh man, I really wanted that role to begin with. Oh, the stuff I will be able to pull! HEHEHE

Villager spotted

Tapatalk

Mafia spotted.

Varcaus
February 3 2013, 02:09:26 AM
Oh god the game hasnt started and my head hurts

Bentguru
February 3 2013, 02:09:34 AM
Fucking Cue, I get a PM and get all excited but NOOOOOOOOOOOOOO, not mafia.

Fuck you cue

Mafia spotted

Tapatalk

Oh man, I had the most awesome idea just now that should win the game for the village once we get a confirmed villager.

Once we do, said confirmed villager should ask everybody in the game to PM them the exact wording of their PM they got from Cue about their role. If Cue cut/paste the PMs, which I suspect he did, the confirmed villager will easily have enough data to separate the normal villagers from the power roles/mafia, and probably enough data on the power roles to differentiate the mafia from the village power roles.

Either way we almost certainly get a huge block of villagers working together. Good idea or no? I don't think there are any holes in it.

pratell
February 3 2013, 02:13:19 AM
zomg where's thread

Qwert
February 3 2013, 02:13:27 AM
Fucking Cue, I get a PM and get all excited but NOOOOOOOOOOOOOO, not mafia.

Fuck you cue

Mafia spotted

Tapatalk

Oh man, I had the most awesome idea just now that should win the game for the village once we get a confirmed villager.

Once we do, said confirmed villager should ask everybody in the game to PM them the exact wording of their PM they got from Cue about their role. If Cue cut/paste the PMs, which I suspect he did, the confirmed villager will easily have enough data to separate the normal villagers from the power roles/mafia, and probably enough data on the power roles to differentiate the mafia from the village power roles.

Either way we almost certainly get a huge block of villagers working together. Good idea or no? I don't think there are any holes in it.

Exept for the whole "-No screenshots. Absolutely none." rule to explicitly prohibit that. At least I think it does.

spasm
February 3 2013, 02:14:18 AM
Are we using this thread?

Lana Torrin
February 3 2013, 02:14:40 AM
inb4 there are no mafia and we are all just lynching eachother for the lols.

Lana Torrin
February 3 2013, 02:15:04 AM
Are we using this thread?

I hope we get a game thread TBH...

Alenar Rumanev
February 3 2013, 02:16:59 AM
Did signups close already? If not I'll join - we need more hangman fodder.

pratell
February 3 2013, 02:17:35 AM
Did signups close already? If not I'll join - we need more hangman fodder.

is over mate, sorry. sounds like another will be starting up soon.

Bentguru
February 3 2013, 02:23:52 AM
Fucking Cue, I get a PM and get all excited but NOOOOOOOOOOOOOO, not mafia.

Fuck you cue

Mafia spotted

Tapatalk

Oh man, I had the most awesome idea just now that should win the game for the village once we get a confirmed villager.

Once we do, said confirmed villager should ask everybody in the game to PM them the exact wording of their PM they got from Cue about their role. If Cue cut/paste the PMs, which I suspect he did, the confirmed villager will easily have enough data to separate the normal villagers from the power roles/mafia, and probably enough data on the power roles to differentiate the mafia from the village power roles.

Either way we almost certainly get a huge block of villagers working together. Good idea or no? I don't think there are any holes in it.

Exept for the whole "-No screenshots. Absolutely none." rule to explicitly prohibit that. At least I think it does.

No it doesn't. Hypothetical confirmed villager would just ask for a PM that included a quote or whatever of the original role PM.

No screenshots needed.

LordsServant
February 3 2013, 02:24:13 AM
http://moviecultists.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/05/Josh-Brolin-in-Gangster-Squad.jpg

THE FEDS ARE HEER.

Gonna beat me up some Mafia. Forming a gangster squad, PM me if you want in.

I need:

-A maverick
-A heavy
-A scout
-A Crazy fuckin doctor (with a Pigeon named Archimedes)
-Some drunk russian

A hot chick would be nice too, to spice up the clubhouse.

=D

cullnean
February 3 2013, 02:25:05 AM
http://moviecultists.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/05/Josh-Brolin-in-Gangster-Squad.jpg

THE FEDS ARE HEER.

Gonna beat me up some Mafia. Forming a gangster squad, PM me if you want in.

I need:

-A maverick
-A heavy
-A scout
-A Crazy fuckin doctor (with a Pigeon named Archimedes)
-Some drunk russian

A hot chick would be nice too, to spice up the clubhouse.

=D

Mate if you survive the first day I'd be suprised

Tapatalk

LordsServant
February 3 2013, 02:25:36 AM
Fucking Cue, I get a PM and get all excited but NOOOOOOOOOOOOOO, not mafia.

Fuck you cue

Mafia spotted

Tapatalk

Oh man, I had the most awesome idea just now that should win the game for the village once we get a confirmed villager.

Once we do, said confirmed villager should ask everybody in the game to PM them the exact wording of their PM they got from Cue about their role. If Cue cut/paste the PMs, which I suspect he did, the confirmed villager will easily have enough data to separate the normal villagers from the power roles/mafia, and probably enough data on the power roles to differentiate the mafia from the village power roles.

Either way we almost certainly get a huge block of villagers working together. Good idea or no? I don't think there are any holes in it.

Exept for the whole "-No screenshots. Absolutely none." rule to explicitly prohibit that. At least I think it does.

No it doesn't. Hypothetical confirmed villager would just ask for a PM that included a quote or whatever of the original role PM.

No screenshots needed.

But the mafia can all just say "I'm the doctor, I'm the lawyer, I'm the sheriff, I'm the village idiot." Quotes of PMs aren't hard to fake. The mafia isn't going to say "oh yeah, look here's Cue telling me I'm mafia." :facepalm:

EchoEpsilon23
February 3 2013, 02:25:54 AM
http://moviecultists.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/05/Josh-Brolin-in-Gangster-Squad.jpg

THE FEDS ARE HEER.

Gonna beat me up some Mafia. Forming a gangster squad, PM me if you want in.

I need:

-A maverick
-A heavy
-A scout
-A Crazy fuckin doctor (with a Pigeon named Archimedes)
-Some drunk russian

A hot chick would be nice too, to spice up the clubhouse.

=D

Mate if you survive the first day I'd be suprised

Tapatalk

I wouldn't be surprised if he's the fed.

LordsServant
February 3 2013, 02:27:43 AM
http://moviecultists.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/05/Josh-Brolin-in-Gangster-Squad.jpg

THE FEDS ARE HEER.

Gonna beat me up some Mafia. Forming a gangster squad, PM me if you want in.

I need:

-A maverick
-A heavy
-A scout
-A Crazy fuckin doctor (with a Pigeon named Archimedes)
-Some drunk russian

A hot chick would be nice too, to spice up the clubhouse.

=D

Mate if you survive the first day I'd be suprised

Tapatalk

M8, if I survive the first day, I'LL be surprised. But thats just what you'd expect eh? Do the unexpected, because everyone expects me to be dead. But what if you do the expected to be unexpectedly expected. Let the mind games and double reverse negative-positive-negatives begin.

My head already hurts, WTB doctor protection for day1 plz. :P

Nicho Void
February 3 2013, 02:28:30 AM
http://moviecultists.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/05/Josh-Brolin-in-Gangster-Squad.jpg

THE FEDS ARE HEER.

Gonna beat me up some Mafia. Forming a gangster squad, PM me if you want in.

I need:

-A maverick
-A heavy
-A scout
-A Crazy fuckin doctor (with a Pigeon named Archimedes)
-Some drunk russian

A hot chick would be nice too, to spice up the clubhouse.

=D
http://www.centerforinquiry.net/uploads/on_campus_blog/Huckleberry.jpg

I'll be your huckleberry.

LordsServant
February 3 2013, 02:29:03 AM
So when do we get the official thread? I'm rather pumped to try this out.

/me puts on robe and wizard hat.

LordsServant
February 3 2013, 02:29:25 AM
http://moviecultists.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/05/Josh-Brolin-in-Gangster-Squad.jpg

THE FEDS ARE HEER.

Gonna beat me up some Mafia. Forming a gangster squad, PM me if you want in.

I need:

-A maverick
-A heavy
-A scout
-A Crazy fuckin doctor (with a Pigeon named Archimedes)
-Some drunk russian

A hot chick would be nice too, to spice up the clubhouse.

=D
http://www.centerforinquiry.net/uploads/on_campus_blog/Huckleberry.jpg

I'll be your huckleberry.

Ur in m8. Bring your own tommy gun. =D

LordsServant
February 3 2013, 02:30:03 AM
Also, I think this game is the best way to +1 your postcount by far.

No editing rule is the best xD

LarkinAlpha
February 3 2013, 02:33:26 AM
Did signups close already? If not I'll join - we need more hangman fodder.

is over mate, sorry. sounds like another will be starting up soon.

I'd like to do the next one, but it'll be 40k with my rofltastic rule set. But I'm not going to start till this one is over. It's already :popcorn: and the game hasn't even started yet!

Lana Torrin
February 3 2013, 02:33:52 AM
Also, I think this game is the best way to +1 your postcount by far.

No editing rule is the best xD

There are other good ways

Varcaus
February 3 2013, 02:34:13 AM
Also, I think this game is the best way to +1 your postcount by far.

No editing rule is the best xD

There are other good ways

tell me about it

EchoEpsilon23
February 3 2013, 02:35:21 AM
Also, I think this game is the best way to +1 your postcount by far.

No editing rule is the best xD

There are other good ways

tell me about it

You start a good thread.

And you make good posts.

Alot of good posts.

And be a good person?

??

Profit!

Varcaus
February 3 2013, 02:36:06 AM
Also, I think this game is the best way to +1 your postcount by far.

No editing rule is the best xD

There are other good ways

tell me about it

You start a good thread.

And you make good posts.

Alot of good posts.

And be a good person?

??

Profit!

Good posting is long slow work m8

LordsServant
February 3 2013, 02:38:35 AM
Also, I think this game is the best way to +1 your postcount by far.

No editing rule is the best xD

There are other good ways

tell me about it

You start a good thread.

And you make good posts.

Alot of good posts.

And be a good person?

??

Profit!

Good posting is long slow work m8

Agreed, sounds like effort. Also, too much goodposting turns your rep bar green. You know what else is green? Sick people.

Sick people should see a doctor, you need a nice healthy red glow in your cheeks; let's you know you're alive m8.

Cue1*
February 3 2013, 02:39:03 AM
Game thread is up. Everyone who got a PM should have noticed my tapatalk PM, which suggests I was on my phone. Didn't copy and paste but a good try none-the-less.

:Tabletz:

cullnean
February 3 2013, 03:01:16 AM
Did signups close already? If not I'll join - we need more hangman fodder.

is over mate, sorry. sounds like another will be starting up soon.

I'd like to do the next one, but it'll be 40k with my rofltastic rule set. But I'm not going to start till this one is over. It's already :popcorn: and the game hasn't even started yet!

Fuck yer

Tapatalk

Lana Torrin
February 3 2013, 03:22:26 AM
Isnt 40K pretty gay though? I mean you have these super strong doped up on god know what drungs guys that 'plant their seed' in youngsters to make them the same as they are.. If thats not a description of a pedo i dont know what is.

LordsServant
February 3 2013, 03:30:13 AM
Isnt 40K pretty gay though? I mean you have these super strong doped up on god know what drungs guys that 'plant their seed' in youngsters to make them the same as they are.. If thats not a description of a pedo i dont know what is.

Wait, what? Srsly?

Never read any 40k and not too familiar, but do they really say "Plant their seed?"

Varcaus
February 3 2013, 03:36:40 AM
Isnt 40K pretty gay though? I mean you have these super strong doped up on god know what drungs guys that 'plant their seed' in youngsters to make them the same as they are.. If thats not a description of a pedo i dont know what is.

Wait, what? Srsly?

Never read any 40k and not too familiar, but do they really say "Plant their seed?"

Nope

pratell
February 3 2013, 03:51:52 AM
Isnt 40K pretty gay though? I mean you have these super strong doped up on god know what drungs guys that 'plant their seed' in youngsters to make them the same as they are.. If thats not a description of a pedo i dont know what is.

Wait, what? Srsly?

Never read any 40k and not too familiar, but do they really say "Plant their seed?"

Nope

Lol no they implant the seed, totally different

Varcaus
February 3 2013, 03:58:56 AM
Isnt 40K pretty gay though? I mean you have these super strong doped up on god know what drungs guys that 'plant their seed' in youngsters to make them the same as they are.. If thats not a description of a pedo i dont know what is.

Wait, what? Srsly?

Never read any 40k and not too familiar, but do they really say "Plant their seed?"

Nope

Lol no they implant the seed, totally different

Ofc its also the geneseed of a dead guy so I guess they are into necrophilia as well.

cullnean
February 3 2013, 04:00:29 AM
Isnt 40K pretty gay though? I mean you have these super strong doped up on god know what drungs guys that 'plant their seed' in youngsters to make them the same as they are.. If thats not a description of a pedo i dont know what is.

Wait, what? Srsly?

Never read any 40k and not too familiar, but do they really say "Plant their seed?"

Nope

Lol no they implant the seed, totally different

Ofc its also the geneseed of a dead guy so I guess they are into necrophilia as well.

Asexual orcs

Tapatalk

Varcaus
February 3 2013, 04:01:48 AM
And plants. Well orcs are plants to but hey.

cullnean
February 3 2013, 04:20:56 AM
And plants. Well orcs are plants to but hey.

Fungus man fungi

Biological observations and shit

Tapatalk

EchoEpsilon23
February 3 2013, 04:25:13 AM
Agreed, sounds like effort. Also, too much goodposting turns your rep bar green. You know what else is green? Sick people.

Sick people should see a doctor, you need a nice healthy red glow in your cheeks; let's you know you're alive m8.

You are right LordsServant, I am sick. Mentally, and Physically, but that's not the point. The point is that good posting, will lead to respect, and respect means power, and power means modding ability, and modding abilities means blackmail, and blackmail means well... nothing, because who cares about internet spaceship forum anyway?

Varcaus
February 3 2013, 04:43:58 AM
And plants. Well orcs are plants to but hey.

Fungus man fungi

Biological observations and shit

Tapatalk

Fungi are plants no?

pratell
February 3 2013, 05:37:29 AM
And plants. Well orcs are plants to but hey.

Fungus man fungi

Biological observations and shit

Tapatalk

Fungi are plants no?
Fungi are plants sure

Sweet jesus

dpidcoe
February 3 2013, 06:47:38 AM
So glad I'm not in this game.

Lana Torrin
February 3 2013, 09:47:58 AM
Can we make a rule that whenever someone talks about the person Me they refer to him as 'the person me' and not just 'me' because its already confusing the fuck out of me (as in myself).

Me
February 3 2013, 10:04:16 AM
Knew it would do this when I chose the username. :lol:

Lana Torrin
February 3 2013, 10:09:25 AM
Knew it would do this when I chose the username. :lol:

You know this is the reason I voted for you right? I dont honestly care what you are...

TheManFromDelmonte
February 3 2013, 10:18:38 AM
So glad I'm not in this game.

Me
February 3 2013, 10:28:49 AM
Knew it would do this when I chose the username. :lol:

You know this is the reason I voted for you right? I dont honestly care what you are...

Just always refer to yourself in the third person. Best bit is with me you can never be sure if I'm talking in the 3rd person or not. :p

Kilabi
February 3 2013, 10:47:39 AM
Did signups close already? If not I'll join - we need more hangman fodder.

is over mate, sorry. sounds like another will be starting up soon.

I'd like to do the next one, but it'll be 40k with my rofltastic rule set. But I'm not going to start till this one is over. It's already :popcorn: and the game hasn't even started yet!

This is a signup.

Nobody_Holme
February 3 2013, 12:24:50 PM
I too wish to sign up for the 40k version.

Inb4 no heretics.

Also, I'd like to run game #5 if people are still interested, I've got a couple of power roles I'd like to try out.

Dorvil Barranis
February 3 2013, 06:26:33 PM
I believe capitalizing the name Me is sufficient. Unless you start a sentence with the word me referring to your self, like "Me good at grammar."

LarkinAlpha
February 3 2013, 07:53:08 PM
Did signups close already? If not I'll join - we need more hangman fodder.

is over mate, sorry. sounds like another will be starting up soon.

I'd like to do the next one, but it'll be 40k with my rofltastic rule set. But I'm not going to start till this one is over. It's already :popcorn: and the game hasn't even started yet!

This is a signup.


I too wish to sign up for the 40k version.

Inb4 no heretics.

Also, I'd like to run game #5 if people are still interested, I've got a couple of power roles I'd like to try out.

Sign Up List (https://docs.google.com/spreadsheet/ccc?key=0Anw5bPpu1b3RdDFzZGhBeHpBUmNxYVFnc28tWGhtS VE&usp=sharing)
I'll make an OOG thread sometime soonish, with all the rules and stuff clearly stated. But I'll take signups as I see them. PM me if you REALLY want in, I'll be sure to get that.

Victoria Steckersaurus
February 3 2013, 08:30:22 PM
Assuming three games in a row of scheming hasn't turned my brain to mush (unlikely) I'll absolutely be down for the WH40K game.

Lana Torrin
February 3 2013, 10:41:19 PM
Someone needs to explain to me what valuable info we get on day 2 that makes not voting a sperging idiot on day 1 worth it.

Varcaus
February 3 2013, 10:44:33 PM
Someone needs to explain to me what valuable info we get on day 2 that makes not voting a sperging idiot on day 1 worth it.

I don't know tbh but i figure vote abstain this time and don't have to deal with this idiocy later.

Steph
February 3 2013, 10:54:08 PM
Someone needs to explain to me what valuable info we get on day 2 that makes not voting a sperging idiot on day 1 worth it.

You can look at it two ways.

Under the no-night rules, Sheriffs get one or possibly two investigations. At best they find a mafia, at worst they remove two villagers from the pool of possible suspects.

Steph
February 3 2013, 10:54:44 PM
By the way, Way 2 is Steph sometimes forgets that he merged his first point with the second and forgot to change the first line of his post.

Lana Torrin
February 4 2013, 12:37:16 AM
Someone needs to explain to me what valuable info we get on day 2 that makes not voting a sperging idiot on day 1 worth it.

You can look at it two ways.

Under the no-night rules, Sheriffs get one or possibly two investigations. At best they find a mafia, at worst they remove two villagers from the pool of possible suspects.

Problem is though, unless you are the sheriff then you don't know this result because literally anyone could be lieing to you, and if you really ARE the Sheriff you would be seriously dumb to post the result. So for everyone else you are left in round 2 with no additional information.

Kilabi
February 4 2013, 03:25:47 AM
But someone has to claim or counter-claim on day 2. Even if the real sheriff did not hit a mafia he can still start to communicate with at least 1 person to start form a clique.

Lana Torrin
February 4 2013, 03:51:42 AM
But someone has to claim or counter-claim on day 2. Even if the real sheriff did not hit a mafia he can still start to communicate with at least 1 person to start form a clique.

I don't think its going to matter to me shortly....

Pacefalm
February 4 2013, 04:47:55 AM
But someone has to claim or counter-claim on day 2. Even if the real sheriff did not hit a mafia he can still start to communicate with at least 1 person to start form a clique.

I don't think its going to matter to me shortly....

It a bit of a bummer but thanks to dwm reveal this lynch will give the village the most info. You can make a case if everyone is voting totally random, that abstaining would be better in that case.

Cheer up, in the worst case scenario you helped out a mafia/the village idiot.

Lana Torrin
February 4 2013, 05:10:44 AM
But someone has to claim or counter-claim on day 2. Even if the real sheriff did not hit a mafia he can still start to communicate with at least 1 person to start form a clique.

I don't think its going to matter to me shortly....

It a bit of a bummer but thanks to dwm reveal this lynch will give the village the most info. You can make a case if everyone is voting totally random, that abstaining would be better in that case.

Cheer up, in the worst case scenario you helped out a mafia/the village idiot.

I'm not unhappy, I would like to play more than 1 round in my first game, but I can see the value of the lynching which is why I changed my vote (ie, so its not a tie between me and Lords)

Varcaus
February 4 2013, 05:14:35 AM
But someone has to claim or counter-claim on day 2. Even if the real sheriff did not hit a mafia he can still start to communicate with at least 1 person to start form a clique.

I don't think its going to matter to me shortly....

It a bit of a bummer but thanks to dwm reveal this lynch will give the village the most info. You can make a case if everyone is voting totally random, that abstaining would be better in that case.

Cheer up, in the worst case scenario you helped out a mafia/the village idiot.

I'm not unhappy, I would like to play more than 1 round in my first game, but I can see the value of the lynching which is why I changed my vote (ie, so its not a tie between me and Lords)

Gunned down my mafia first time. Couldn't even defend myself. ;_;

Lana Torrin
February 4 2013, 05:17:43 AM
But someone has to claim or counter-claim on day 2. Even if the real sheriff did not hit a mafia he can still start to communicate with at least 1 person to start form a clique.

I don't think its going to matter to me shortly....

It a bit of a bummer but thanks to dwm reveal this lynch will give the village the most info. You can make a case if everyone is voting totally random, that abstaining would be better in that case.

Cheer up, in the worst case scenario you helped out a mafia/the village idiot.

I'm not unhappy, I would like to play more than 1 round in my first game, but I can see the value of the lynching which is why I changed my vote (ie, so its not a tie between me and Lords)

Gunned down my mafia first time. Couldn't even defend myself. ;_;

Its being a productive first round anyway.

dpidcoe
February 4 2013, 06:33:05 AM
This game is even more full of retard than the last two from what I've read so far.

Qwert
February 4 2013, 06:34:20 AM
This game is even more full of retard than the last two from what I've read so far.

Cue let Lords in. You expected anything less?

Kilabi
February 4 2013, 06:53:03 AM
By the looks of it we will be playing another game in a few days anyway.

Lana Torrin
February 4 2013, 07:14:16 AM
This game is even more full of retard than the last two from what I've read so far.
I dont know its been quite fun.. I'll be up for another game in a couple o days.

dpidcoe
February 4 2013, 07:17:58 AM
This game is even more full of retard than the last two from what I've read so far.

Cue let Lords in. You expected anything less?

We need a banlist for the next mafia game tbh.

ctrlchris
February 4 2013, 07:54:38 AM
This game is even more full of retard than the last two from what I've read so far.

Cue let Lords in. You expected anything less?

We need a banlist for the next mafia game tbh.

Anyone who has been a total bellend gets on it.

Lana Torrin
February 4 2013, 08:42:48 AM
This game is even more full of retard than the last two from what I've read so far.

Cue let Lords in. You expected anything less?

We need a banlist for the next mafia game tbh.

Anyone who has been a total bellend gets on it.

I'm a shoe in

Lana Torrin
February 4 2013, 11:31:28 AM
So the citizens are aware that the idea is to kill off the mafia right? Not fool everyone in to thinking you have a power..

cullnean
February 4 2013, 01:14:22 PM
So the citizens are aware that the idea is to kill off the mafia right? Not fool everyone in to thinking you have a power..

welcome to fhc mafia

pratell
February 4 2013, 04:39:46 PM
Cue, is the village nut simply an inverted sheriff or do they have different rates of (mis)identification?

Qwert
February 4 2013, 06:22:05 PM
So what specifically will the nut get when he investigates?

"Nut- Village. Thinks he's sheriff but receives bad info or failures for investigations."

Will it be totally random? exactly opposite with wrong roles? 90% fail?

Generally will be opposite. Failure and potentially correct just often enough to make the player believe he IS a sheriff.

Lana Torrin
February 4 2013, 10:56:00 PM
Cue, is the village nut simply an inverted sheriff or do they have different rates of (mis)identification?

I'm more interested in what happens when the nut knows they are the nut. Do they start getting legit info? I mean otherwise they are shortly going to become more useful than the sheriff.

Dorvil Barranis
February 5 2013, 12:10:03 AM
Cue, is the village nut simply an inverted sheriff or do they have different rates of (mis)identification?

I'm more interested in what happens when the nut knows they are the nut. Do they start getting legit info? I mean otherwise they are shortly going to become more useful than the sheriff.

Nut would be more of a nut if they got a random result each time. If they always get the opposite of the correct result, then they become an odd sheriff.

EchoEpsilon23
February 5 2013, 02:10:49 AM
That was nice run, well at least I know one thing, that lords is actually mafia, and I can probably guess the rest. It's just shame really, I protected some one and I end up dying to the mafia. Tsk tsk tsk. Oh well, my plan of acting as the village idiot while protecting various certain individuals, which I will not tell worked horribly and probably what got me killed.

DrumWithMe2012
February 5 2013, 02:21:32 AM
I think I liked playing when I didn't actually have a role. This was over all to quick. I also didn't say jack last time in any conversation. I'll be interested to see how this actually plays out.

Victoria Steckersaurus
February 5 2013, 02:55:59 AM
I think I liked playing when I didn't actually have a role. This was over all to quick. I also didn't say jack last time in any conversation. I'll be interested to see how this actually plays out.

as a piece of advice, when you have a role, don't say so for at least a couple of days.

And yeah, dying early in mafia sucks, but someone has to :(

spasm
February 5 2013, 02:57:22 AM
That was nice run, well at least I know one thing, that lords is actually mafia, and I can probably guess the rest. It's just shame really, I protected some one and I end up dying to the mafia. Tsk tsk tsk. Oh well, my plan of acting as the village idiot while protecting various certain individuals, which I will not tell worked horribly and probably what got me killed.

Dead men don't talk, stop revealing everything you learned after dying.

Lana Torrin
February 5 2013, 03:00:38 AM
I think I liked playing when I didn't actually have a role. This was over all to quick. I also didn't say jack last time in any conversation. I'll be interested to see how this actually plays out.

as a piece of advice, when you have a role, don't say so for at least a couple of days.

And yeah, dying early in mafia sucks, but someone has to :(

I was fine with the idea because it would have proven something.. Bit annoyed that our Vigilante killed an obvious villager though..

pratell
February 5 2013, 03:14:55 AM
I think I liked playing when I didn't actually have a role. This was over all to quick. I also didn't say jack last time in any conversation. I'll be interested to see how this actually plays out.

as a piece of advice, when you have a role, don't say so for at least a couple of days.

And yeah, dying early in mafia sucks, but someone has to :(

I was fine with the idea because it would have proven something.. Bit annoyed that our Vigilante killed an obvious villager though..

even batman got a few wrong

LarkinAlpha
February 5 2013, 03:16:31 AM
I think I liked playing when I didn't actually have a role. This was over all to quick. I also didn't say jack last time in any conversation. I'll be interested to see how this actually plays out.

as a piece of advice, when you have a role, don't say so for at least a couple of days.

And yeah, dying early in mafia sucks, but someone has to :(

I was fine with the idea because it would have proven something.. Bit annoyed that our Vigilante killed an obvious villager though..

even batman got a few wrong

Not the hero FHC wanted, but the hero FHC deserves...

Me
February 5 2013, 03:32:55 AM
I think I liked playing when I didn't actually have a role. This was over all to quick. I also didn't say jack last time in any conversation. I'll be interested to see how this actually plays out.

as a piece of advice, when you have a role, don't say so for at least a couple of days.

And yeah, dying early in mafia sucks, but someone has to :(

I was fine with the idea because it would have proven something.. Bit annoyed that our Vigilante killed an obvious villager though..

even batman got a few wrong

Not the hero FHC wanted, but the hero FHC deserves...

http://i.imgur.com/DF3XKGT.png

Where did that hat come from?

Lana Torrin
February 5 2013, 06:25:45 AM
I hate you all for not lynching me now.. All I have been doing all day is going over the clusterfuck of the intel I have to work out who I can trust and who I cant..

Lana Torrin
February 5 2013, 09:18:00 AM
OK so at what point in the day do we say everyone has had a chance to see what has happened and then formulate their lie to get me to protect them?

Me
February 5 2013, 09:38:02 AM
OK so at what point in the day do we say everyone has had a chance to see what has happened and then formulate their lie to get me to protect them?

Try to keep this stuff in the other thread and this one for asking Cue rules questions.

Lana Torrin
February 5 2013, 10:03:50 AM
OK so at what point in the day do we say everyone has had a chance to see what has happened and then formulate their lie to get me to protect them?

Try to keep this stuff in the other thread and this one for asking Cue rules questions.
It was more of a question of what timezone spread do we have...

Me
February 5 2013, 10:08:45 AM
OK so at what point in the day do we say everyone has had a chance to see what has happened and then formulate their lie to get me to protect them?

Try to keep this stuff in the other thread and this one for asking Cue rules questions.
It was more of a question of what timezone spread do we have...

For the most part Americans I think, with a few Euros and me, you and Chris as Aussies.

Lana Torrin
February 5 2013, 10:28:29 AM
OK so at what point in the day do we say everyone has had a chance to see what has happened and then formulate their lie to get me to protect them?

Try to keep this stuff in the other thread and this one for asking Cue rules questions.
It was more of a question of what timezone spread do we have...

For the most part Americans I think, with a few Euros and me, you and Chris as Aussies.

By 'me' do you mean yourself or.. oh wait..

Me
February 5 2013, 10:33:21 AM
OK so at what point in the day do we say everyone has had a chance to see what has happened and then formulate their lie to get me to protect them?

Try to keep this stuff in the other thread and this one for asking Cue rules questions.
It was more of a question of what timezone spread do we have...

For the most part Americans I think, with a few Euros and me, you and Chris as Aussies.

By 'me' do you mean yourself or.. oh wait..

:derper:

pratell
February 5 2013, 12:21:20 PM
I'm an American

Cue1*
February 5 2013, 05:41:19 PM
Or lords is a retard who never should have been allowed to play and a lot of us don't want to deal with him.

Sent from the SpasPhone

I'm not going to ban someone for their posting outside of the game. People who break the rules, however, will be banned. Echo is banned from my future games. His claims(true or not) have changed the dynamic of the game after he died.

Kanv
February 5 2013, 09:50:31 PM
Or lords is a retard who never should have been allowed to play and a lot of us don't want to deal with him.

Sent from the SpasPhone

I'm not going to ban someone for their posting outside of the game. People who break the rules, however, will be banned. Echo is banned from my future games. His claims(true or not) have changed the dynamic of the game after he died.
What did he do?

pratell
February 5 2013, 09:57:33 PM
Or lords is a retard who never should have been allowed to play and a lot of us don't want to deal with him.

Sent from the SpasPhone

I'm not going to ban someone for their posting outside of the game. People who break the rules, however, will be banned. Echo is banned from my future games. His claims(true or not) have changed the dynamic of the game after he died.
What did he do?told everyone he was the doctor.

EchoEpsilon23
February 5 2013, 10:37:10 PM
Fair enough.

dpidcoe
February 6 2013, 06:38:57 AM
This is by far the derpiest game of mafia to date imo.

There's so much :psyduck: in the reasoning going on in that thread.

Lana Torrin
February 6 2013, 07:26:22 AM
This is by far the derpiest game of mafia to date imo.

There's so much :psyduck: in the reasoning going on in that thread.

TBH I'm guessing there is a reason for some of the derp.. Fucking lords, why did you have to try and :lolpowerroll: on turn one..

Tyrehl
February 6 2013, 07:32:24 AM
If he tried not to attract that much attention on day one he could've saved us a lot of time. Well at least I hope they got the turncoat by accident.

Edit: also the vigilante. Jesus christ, mate if you read this - start playing for the village or just kill me tonight, I have exams to take so you'll save me some time.

Lana Torrin
February 6 2013, 07:49:33 AM
If he tried not to attract that much attention on day one he could've saved us a lot of time. Well at least I hope they got the turncoat by accident.

Edit: also the vigilante. Jesus christ, mate if you read this - start playing for the village or just kill me tonight, I have exams to take so you'll save me some time.

TBH this gos for all of the villigers.. FFS this game is hard enough when everyone is playing it properly, when you are an innocent AND A RETARD it just makes it all the more harder..

ctrlchris
February 6 2013, 08:53:49 AM
If he tried not to attract that much attention on day one he could've saved us a lot of time. Well at least I hope they got the turncoat by accident.

Edit: also the vigilante. Jesus christ, mate if you read this - start playing for the village or just kill me tonight, I have exams to take so you'll save me some time.

TBH this gos for all of the villigers.. FFS this game is hard enough when everyone is playing it properly, when you are an innocent AND A RETARD it just makes it all the more harder..

The problem with idiots is that they dont know they are idiots.

Kilabi
February 6 2013, 08:55:31 AM
Normally we should have some powerroles coming forward and starting to blame people. Or at least some votingblocks forming or anything. But those FHC games with ex-EvEers everywhere are so void of trust that bandwagoning just makes it too easy for the mafiaplayers.
Just accuse random people at all time and the village will eat itself.

cullnean
February 6 2013, 09:08:51 AM
If he tried not to attract that much attention on day one he could've saved us a lot of time. Well at least I hope they got the turncoat by accident.

Edit: also the vigilante. Jesus christ, mate if you read this - start playing for the village or just kill me tonight, I have exams to take so you'll save me some time.

TBH this gos for all of the villigers.. FFS this game is hard enough when everyone is playing it properly, when you are an innocent AND A RETARD it just makes it all the more harder..

The problem with idiots is that they dont know they are idiots.

Nobody_Holme
February 6 2013, 09:44:28 AM
Normally we should have some powerroles coming forward and starting to blame people. Or at least some votingblocks forming or anything. But those FHC games with ex-EvEers everywhere are so void of trust that bandwagoning just makes it too easy for the mafiaplayers.
Just accuse random people at all time and the village will eat itself.

Its more that the clique-ish types (myself included a bit) will avoid talking in public to avoid those who're unwilling to join in (henceforth known as "the bads", however true or untrue that is) picking on them for talking much.

Lana Torrin
February 6 2013, 12:06:57 PM
Do some people have multiple roles? The implication was 1 role per person.

If some people DO have multiple roles im going to need a lot of clarifications on how these roles interact.

ctrlchris
February 6 2013, 12:39:36 PM
One role per person

Lana Torrin
February 6 2013, 01:14:34 PM
One role per person

I know thats how its normally played but I need Cue to tell me because my vote depends on it now.

dpidcoe
February 6 2013, 04:37:41 PM
Normally we should have some powerroles coming forward and starting to blame people. Or at least some votingblocks forming or anything. But those FHC games with ex-EvEers everywhere are so void of trust that bandwagoning just makes it too easy for the mafiaplayers.
Just accuse random people at all time and the village will eat itself.
Mafia doesn't even need to accuse anyone, all the villagers are witch hunting anyway. Also, they're accusing people based on the dumbest things. If this were a game with people who didn't do retarded things, it would be easy to spot the mafia (they'd be the ones using weird reasoning). The problem is that in all of the games so far (and especially this one), people acting weird are more likely to be retarded villagers than mafia, which leaves a great cover for the mafia.

Cue1*
February 6 2013, 05:09:58 PM
Do some people have multiple roles? The implication was 1 role per person.

If some people DO have multiple roles im going to need a lot of clarifications on how these roles interact.

One role per person.

Lana Torrin
February 7 2013, 01:58:01 AM
So today this game got me so caught up in trying to work out who is who I almost got fired..

Varcaus
February 7 2013, 02:06:05 AM
So today this game got me so caught up in trying to work out who is who I almost got fired..

Maaaaate

Kilabi
February 7 2013, 05:10:24 AM
Game needs a NSFW tag now.

Lana Torrin
February 7 2013, 08:21:38 AM
What are we doing on the weekend. I usually don't post much on weekends because that's when I have my life and I feel if I'm still alive I could be key to both sides success.. (or not, they should both know by now not to talk to me)

Cue1*
February 7 2013, 08:36:35 AM
What are we doing on the weekend. I usually don't post much on weekends because that's when I have my life and I feel if I'm still alive I could be key to both sides success.. (or not, they should both know by now not to talk to me)
Something worth discussing. I'm willing to call the weekend one long day, or I can cycle the days as normal.

Me
February 7 2013, 09:45:42 AM
What are we doing on the weekend.

Well I'm going out for dinner on Saturday but I'll be free the rest of the time~~~

Lana Torrin
February 8 2013, 04:55:29 AM
Seeing as no one else seems to care, and I am in well over my head, why don't we just continue doing 24h days over the weekend. Get this game over with faster.

Bentguru
February 8 2013, 05:19:45 AM
If you're going to be so defeatist then just send me your PM history. Either I am mafia and the village still loses, or i am not and I give the village a chance at winning

Lana Torrin
February 8 2013, 05:24:26 AM
If you're going to be so defeatist then just send me your PM history. Either I am mafia and the village still loses, or i am not and I give the village a chance at winning
Hahaha.

Never say never.

Bentguru
February 8 2013, 05:33:01 AM
If you're going to be so defeatist then just send me your PM history. Either I am mafia and the village still loses, or i am not and I give the village a chance at winning
Hahaha.

Never say never.

You're doing a fantastic job of helping the mafia win, you really are. I honestly hope you're the turncoat, at least this village wont lose to villa idiocy

Lana Torrin
February 8 2013, 10:48:29 PM
I think too many roles has made the people without them depressed..

Steph
February 8 2013, 11:28:26 PM
So since there's apparently only one lynch left before the end of the game, time to start thinking about Round 4?

I'd a mind to throw my hat back into the moderator's ring for this game, unless anyone else had their heart set on being god for a week or two.

Me
February 8 2013, 11:31:35 PM
So since there's apparently only one lynch left before the end of the game, time to start thinking about Round 4?

I'd a mind to throw my hat back into the moderator's ring for this game, unless anyone else had their heart set on being god for a week or two.

someone was talking about a 40k one.

Lana Torrin
February 8 2013, 11:33:30 PM
So since there's apparently only one lynch left before the end of the game, time to start thinking about Round 4?

I'd a mind to throw my hat back into the moderator's ring for this game, unless anyone else had their heart set on being god for a week or two.

someone was talking about a 40k one.
Edit: Fuck this is the OOG thread..

Yeah there is a 40k one taking bets but I dont want to be in that one. Happy to sign up for another vanilla one soon though.

pratell
February 8 2013, 11:59:09 PM
i'd run a vanilla one starting monday if no one else is lined up to start one.

Lana Torrin
February 9 2013, 12:00:43 AM
i'd run a vanilla one starting monday if no one else is lined up to start one.

Can I not be hung out as a target for mistrust and misinformation on day 1?

Pacefalm
February 9 2013, 12:12:42 AM
Hmmz I don't know. Last few weeks playing mafia all day erryday has burned me out quite quickly. Maybe give it a week or so before we barge into another one? The general feeling from the current round is "yeah whatever"

Steph
February 9 2013, 12:12:47 AM
i'd run a vanilla one starting monday if no one else is lined up to start one.

Can I not be hung out as a target for mistrust and misinformation on day 1?

inb4 lana is village idiot

Pacefalm
February 9 2013, 12:14:26 AM
m8 keep up with the times
Victoria was village idiot

Lana Torrin
February 9 2013, 12:29:36 AM
m8 keep up with the times
Victoria was village idiot

Yeah im the turncoat.. geez..

Nobody_Holme
February 9 2013, 01:13:59 AM
I had my name down to run another non-40k one, but I dont want to snipe larkin's game, so holding at least until thats over.

I've got the maths worked out on a couple of added roles too, which should spice life up a bit for the people who get them at least. (and if someone smart gets one of them, erryone)

spasm
February 9 2013, 01:16:04 AM
Why don't we just play a game where we read people's post and try and figure out if people are mafia or not instead of giving every single person a goofy role and making things stupidly complicated.

TheManFromDelmonte
February 9 2013, 01:19:07 AM
We should have a post with an official mod queue.

And it'll give us another thread to take over the forum until we're given a subforum.

Nobody_Holme
February 9 2013, 01:27:12 AM
Why don't we just play a game where we read people's post and try and figure out if people are mafia or not instead of giving every single person a goofy role and making things stupidly complicated.

Because you've seen how well the village does at that.

also, goofy roles are what vary the thing. And some of them (hi fed) are amusing foils to people being fucking retarded all the time (okay, no they're not, but they DO make it amusing when that happens)
If everyone playing played as well as the few people who've handled themselves right, then sure, we'd be better off without adding anything in, but as it is, theres one game being played by the people who know whats going on and another being played by the rest, which is mostly being led around by the nose, hence why some people are getting bored. Give it time to settle down and the stronger players to get more of an even distribution between teams, and we can go over to the basic game again.

Wrack
February 9 2013, 01:28:02 AM
We should have a post with an official mod queue.

And it'll give us another thread to take over the forum until we're given a subforum.

Quackbot moderates a game, last man standing becomes next moderator.

Pacefalm
February 9 2013, 01:29:30 AM
We should have a post with an official mod queue.

And it'll give us another thread to take over the forum until we're given a subforum.

Quackbot moderates a game, winners become future moderators.
That's a great idea

Lana Torrin
February 9 2013, 01:31:31 AM
If everyone playing played

I think that right there has caused us a couple of issues in the recent game. I could be wrong as I don't know what everyone is yet so I don't know WHY people are claiming they lost interest, but Inora wasn't the first person to tell me this,.

Nobody_Holme
February 9 2013, 01:49:06 AM
If its going to go like that, i'll just throw the roles i was going to add out there for people to consider.

Mason Grandmaster: Villager, can induct people to the masons as he chooses. Only the grandmaster can recruit, rule 1 of the masons is dont talk about them in public (naming yourself as one or giving too strong a hint that you are one in public will cause you to die the following night). anyone, including mafia, can become masons, if the grandmaster dies, all current masons get to elect a new grandmaster. All investigations carried out by masons have the results (NOT the person carrying out the investigation's name) handed to the grandmaster at the time they are carried out.

Mason: Inducted by grand master, knows a secret passcode (handshake) that can be used to identify to other masons in private channels, if the grandmaster chooses to keep the identities of masons from each other. Can be a mafia.

Don: As previous games, but shows as guilty when investigated.

Mafioso: As before

Enforcer: Mafia member that carries out the hits.

Crooked cop: As sheriff (with additional rules for this game), all investigation results copied to don. Shares mafia AND village win conditions until investigated, then becomes standard mafia (if it was the sheriff who checked) or ceases to share village win (if the PI checked - retains powers in this case).

Sheriff: can check one person per night, OR post the results of any prior check publicly (does not reveal by doing this, it's through a GM post).

Don's girl: (or guy, but lets assume we're going with 50s style, so has to at least appear to be female for the don not to lose his role...) Knows who the don is, and the PI. Special win condition: Wins ONLY if she and the PI survive, regardless of mafia or village victory.

Village idiot: as past games. best given to someone like lords to teach you fuckers not to kill someone for bad reasons.

PI: Knows who the dons girl is. Can investigate someone every night, CANNOT post this publicly except in the thread like current sheriffs. Special win condition: survive with don's girl alive, and don dead. (note, his win condition is NOT the same as the don's girl) If the don has a certain identity for the PI, the enforcer will be sent after the PI, and both will die. Don's girl then gains mafia win condition.

Doc: As before

No more than 2*doc, 1/4 population mafia, 2*legit and 1*crooked sheriff. For maximum hilarity, have multiple don's girls, all playing with the same PI and don, and PI and Don can only win if ONE girl lives, separate from all other win/loss states.

These are from rough notes, so please feel free to improve on them. (or tell me they're shit)

spasm
February 9 2013, 02:11:18 AM
There isn't a big enough psyduck for FHC and the mafia game.

Lana Torrin
February 9 2013, 02:36:37 AM
There isn't a big enough psyduck for FHC and the mafia game.

Complete lack of trust will do that.

Victoria Steckersaurus
February 9 2013, 03:17:01 AM
Well, personally I'm having a blast, but that comes from being successful two games in a row. I understand they've been frustrating for other people (as the first one was for me) and I'm a little worried bent is going to blow a blood vessel.

It might be worth waiting on running another game. Or putting a fucking massive disclaimer that you shouldn't play if you're feeling tired of the game, leave it open for the people who want to invest the time and have the energy.

The WH40K game looks like it could be a ton of fun, but it could also be a massive clusterfuck that creates a heaping pile of horribly frustrating :psyduck:

Some of us seem to be competitive. I certainly am.

Lana Torrin
February 9 2013, 03:20:09 AM
I would like to play a game where the roles and minimal and the numbers known (eg, 2 docs, 1 sheriff, etc). Don't need to know the number of mafia..

Bentguru
February 9 2013, 03:20:33 AM
and I'm a little worried bent is going to blow a blood vessel.

IF THEY WOULD ONLY LISTEN TO ME WE COULD WIN!!!!!!!

http://i.imgur.com/fLuZiCH.gif

Lana Torrin
February 9 2013, 03:21:42 AM
and I'm a little worried bent is going to blow a blood vessel.

IF THEY WOULD ONLY LISTEN TO ME WE COULD WIN!!!!!!!

http://i.imgur.com/fLuZiCH.gif

Yeah sorry about that.. Winding you up was the only way I could think of testing you.

Bentguru
February 9 2013, 03:22:39 AM
lol, you can't take credit for it... it's been a village-wide endeavor.

and you still aren't listening fyi

Lana Torrin
February 9 2013, 03:24:23 AM
lol, you can't take credit for it... it's been a village-wide endeavor.

and you still aren't listening fyi

hahahaha.. I know

I told you, no one knows what im doing.

Bentguru
February 9 2013, 03:25:16 AM
cause you're schizo imo

dpidcoe
February 9 2013, 03:36:29 AM
Why don't we just play a game where we read people's post and try and figure out if people are mafia or not instead of giving every single person a goofy role and making things stupidly complicated.

Because you've seen how well the village does at that.
Village should do better next time with a more vanilla game and all of the retards banned. Especially if there's a bit of hand-tweaking of randomly assigned roles to distribute the players more evenly.

Nicho Void
February 9 2013, 03:46:03 AM
I don't know why everyone is so surprised. The entire set of power roles + no role reveal on death was designed from the start to be as confusing as possible.

Lana Torrin
February 9 2013, 03:48:18 AM
I don't know why everyone is so surprised. The entire set of power roles + no role reveal on death was designed from the start to be as confusing as possible.

Yeah I didn't read the no role reveal on death part until the game had already started.. Makes mafia way to easy..

Qwert
February 9 2013, 04:39:21 AM
I'm playing the next game with a random number generator in the other tab, and voting to it blindly.

Guaranteed I'll do better than you bandwaggoning sheep. :obama:

LarkinAlpha
February 9 2013, 05:21:10 AM
Just note, my rules set is designed to keep the most citizens alive for the longest amount of time. Just saying...

Lana Torrin
February 9 2013, 06:38:52 AM
I'm playing the next game with a random number generator in the other tab, and voting to it blindly.

Guaranteed I'll do better than you bandwaggoning sheep. :obama:

To be fair there has been a lot going on that you haven't had access to.

Pacefalm
February 9 2013, 09:57:28 AM
Role reveal on death is necessary imho...

Me
February 9 2013, 10:43:39 AM
meh. Only game so far that the village has done well was the first where nothing was revealed on death.

More info = worse performance.

Pacefalm
February 9 2013, 10:47:01 AM
I disagree. The village won but they did not play well at all... Or did you forget zumwalt and nicho
Only reason village won that is thanks to bentguru being terrible too

LordsServant
February 9 2013, 11:05:32 AM
This is just such lolz. Not a single mafia has been killed, you've lynched the shit out of your power roles(cannot elaborate further due to rules), a d villagers are dropping like flies.

Not sure what to say except lolvillage.

Btw, has anyone thought to consider maybe Lana was the turncoat? Villager in the beginning, got revealed and confirmed as a villager, then turncoated = ultimate mafia bro. Has access to all the info from everyone. Obviously knows who other mafia is, so knows the truth on everyone.

Despite me pointing out exactly who I was(pretty important) and going so far as to try to offer what proof I could, the day after Lana herself started a lynch mob on me.

That just seems, to me, to be hugely suspicious.

I haven't been following thread that much, but is the federale still alive? Or any of our sherriffs?

Lief Siddhe
February 9 2013, 11:23:26 AM
From following the mafia threads, seems to me for the village to win the sheriff needs to anounce himself from the start (his first and all following investigations made public) with docs protecting the shit out of him secretly. Roles such as village idiot and turncoat make the game too easy for mafia in forum format.

I could be totally wrong since i never played

Lana Torrin
February 9 2013, 11:23:28 AM
This is just such lolz. Not a single mafia has been killed, you've lynched the shit out of your power roles(cannot elaborate further due to rules), a d villagers are dropping like flies.

Not sure what to say except lolvillage.

Btw, has anyone thought to consider maybe Lana was the turncoat? Villager in the beginning, got revealed and confirmed as a villager, then turncoated = ultimate mafia bro. Has access to all the info from everyone. Obviously knows who other mafia is, so knows the truth on everyone.

Despite me pointing out exactly who I was(pretty important) and going so far as to try to offer what proof I could, the day after Lana herself started a lynch mob on me.

That just seems, to me, to be hugely suspicious.

I haven't been following thread that much, but is the federale still alive? Or any of our sherriffs?

For a reason as to why I hung you out to dry see the other mafra thread. you provided no evidence other than 'I told someone else the same thing'. Now I realize doc is hard to prove but the bandwagon was already going and I had an opportunity (I thought) for some real info.. But as it turns out :echo:...

Edit: I can make all the excuses in the world for this game, but not getting rolls on death and people giving up half way has made it very hard to distinguish between mafia/idle people/frightened civies/people getting in to my head.. Plus you know, the general distrust ex-eve players have with each other.

TheManFromDelmonte
February 9 2013, 11:30:12 AM
The village idiot actually isn't that big a deal, lynching them is one lost lynch and as we've seen the village can lose lynches all over at the best of times.

If someone steps up day 1 and says they're the idiot I'd be happy to lynch them to stop people hiding behind it in future.

Also it's really totally unnecessary to have a cop. It helps a lot sure, but if people are actually thinking and playing well the mafia can't lead the town and then they get caught. Some town members have actually done a good job of spotting mafia in the past few games, but some haven't and half the village vs the other half + mafia means the mafia win.

LordsServant
February 9 2013, 11:40:34 AM
This is just such lolz. Not a single mafia has been killed, you've lynched the shit out of your power roles(cannot elaborate further due to rules), a d villagers are dropping like flies.

Not sure what to say except lolvillage.

Btw, has anyone thought to consider maybe Lana was the turncoat? Villager in the beginning, got revealed and confirmed as a villager, then turncoated = ultimate mafia bro. Has access to all the info from everyone. Obviously knows who other mafia is, so knows the truth on everyone.

Despite me pointing out exactly who I was(pretty important) and going so far as to try to offer what proof I could, the day after Lana herself started a lynch mob on me.

That just seems, to me, to be hugely suspicious.

I haven't been following thread that much, but is the federale still alive? Or any of our sherriffs?

For a reason as to why I hung you out to dry see the other mafra thread. you provided no evidence other than 'I told someone else the same thing'. Now I realize doc is hard to prove but the bandwagon was already going and I had an opportunity (I thought) for some real info.. But as it turns out :echo:...

Edit: I can make all the excuses in the world for this game, but not getting rolls on death and people giving up half way has made it very hard to distinguish between mafia/idle people/frightened civies/people getting in to my head.. Plus you know, the general distrust ex-eve players have with each other.

I don't think I'm breaking the rules since you said I was doctor first(still cannot publicly confirm/deny til game is over due to the rules).

Why would you lynch someone who could possibly be a doctor for "more info?"

You should've protected, let me prove to you that I am absolutely a doctor(or not), and then made a decision from there.

Instead, you took me not answering a question(because I work a ridiculous amount of hours at ridiculous times) as me somehow being guilty because someone else claimed the same role. Wat?

If you were turncoat, you'd know who exactly were mafia bros, and who weren't. Me claiming doctor to u in a pm would be pretty believable since you'd already know I'm ot mafia trying to lie.

Me being myself, and the hilarious herd mentality of certain members of this forum meant it would be very easy to start a bandwagon aganst myself, meaning mafia didn't even have to waste a hit to remove what is almost certainly a confirmed doctor.

Unless ppl are really that retarded as to just randomly lynch me just because(which is well and truly retarded if we're on the same side and i would've been a p. big element in the villages success if I were still alive), then all other signs (from my pov) would lead to you looking heavily like the turncoat.

Lana Torrin
February 9 2013, 11:47:41 AM
This is just such lolz. Not a single mafia has been killed, you've lynched the shit out of your power roles(cannot elaborate further due to rules), a d villagers are dropping like flies.

Not sure what to say except lolvillage.

Btw, has anyone thought to consider maybe Lana was the turncoat? Villager in the beginning, got revealed and confirmed as a villager, then turncoated = ultimate mafia bro. Has access to all the info from everyone. Obviously knows who other mafia is, so knows the truth on everyone.

Despite me pointing out exactly who I was(pretty important) and going so far as to try to offer what proof I could, the day after Lana herself started a lynch mob on me.

That just seems, to me, to be hugely suspicious.

I haven't been following thread that much, but is the federale still alive? Or any of our sherriffs?

For a reason as to why I hung you out to dry see the other mafra thread. you provided no evidence other than 'I told someone else the same thing'. Now I realize doc is hard to prove but the bandwagon was already going and I had an opportunity (I thought) for some real info.. But as it turns out :echo:...

Edit: I can make all the excuses in the world for this game, but not getting rolls on death and people giving up half way has made it very hard to distinguish between mafia/idle people/frightened civies/people getting in to my head.. Plus you know, the general distrust ex-eve players have with each other.

I don't think I'm breaking the rules since you said I was doctor first(still cannot publicly confirm/deny til game is over due to the rules).

Why would you lynch someone who could possibly be a doctor for "more info?"

You should've protected, let me prove to you that I am absolutely a doctor(or not), and then made a decision from there.

Instead, you took me not answering a question(because I work a ridiculous amount of hours at ridiculous times) as me somehow being guilty because someone else claimed the same role. Wat?

If you were turncoat, you'd know who exactly were mafia bros, and who weren't. Me claiming doctor to u in a pm would be pretty believable since you'd already know I'm ot mafia trying to lie.

Me being myself, and the hilarious herd mentality of certain members of this forum meant it would be very easy to start a bandwagon aganst myself, meaning mafia didn't even have to waste a hit to remove what is almost certainly a confirmed doctor.

Unless ppl are really that retarded as to just randomly lynch me just because(which is well and truly retarded if we're on the same side and i would've been a p. big element in the villages success if I were still alive), then all other signs (from my pov) would lead to you looking heavily like the turncoat.

Mate I got "I'll just have a shower then tell you" as the answer to the question.. I thought you had drowned or something. I didn't believe a word you had said and you weren't able to confirm any of it, or get anyone to back you up. The bandwagon was already well in effect before I voted, you were going to die one way or another very shortly. Some people actually don't like you lords, that's why you were picked, there is nothing random about it and there was nothing I could say to stop it other than telling everyone I thought you were our 2nd doctor and getting you assassinated next round. Is that a stupid reason to pick you? Yes it is. Is there anything I could have done about it?

LordsServant
February 9 2013, 11:53:01 AM
I don't think we're allowed to release pm's, and I think I'm already pushing the limits of the rules here without specifically getting confirmation from cue.

I'm gonna just let things be for now, and I guess all will be revealed at games end. ;)

Not very hard to see this game is all but lost for village, so maybe next game people will be able to actually think and not just jump on shitstorming bandwagons(which I think have been agreed to be absolutely useless for at least 2 games now...they just help the mafia).

Save the poast, maybe I'm right, mabe I'm wrong. I have my reasons, you have yours. ;)

Lana Torrin
February 9 2013, 12:03:26 PM
I don't think we're allowed to release pm's, and I think I'm already pushing the limits of the rules here without specifically getting confirmation from cue.

I'm gonna just let things be for now, and I guess all will be revealed at games end. ;)

Not very hard to see this game is all but lost for village, so maybe next game people will be able to actually think and not just jump on shitstorming bandwagons(which I think have been agreed to be absolutely useless for at least 2 games now...they just help the mafia).

Save the poast, maybe I'm right, mabe I'm wrong. I have my reasons, you have yours. ;)

I'm pretty sure its not going to turn out how you think. I mean its a village loss sure, but not for the reasons you want.

My biggest screw up at the start was believing echo was a doc. That significantly changed how I was thinking things were going down. I also thought with the number of players we had and the number of roles we had 1 of each role and 2 docs.. Turns out that's not the case either (I thought this was actually in the rules, but I have since checked and it was a stupid assumption I made from how they were written).

It also doesn't help that the 1 or 2 times I have actually thought I had a grasp on what was going on, people haven't done what I asked. Cul was a great example of this. Asked him to hit someone as his second target, he agrees and then he hit someone else. Conclusion, he didn't hit them because he couldn't hit them, therefor he wasn't the vigilante that he was claiming to be.. Pitch forks, fire, the works, another dead villager..

I've since found out why he did this and TBH I don't blame him, but it made him look mafia.

A couple of people still alive are treading this path as well, I've pretty much given up on them.

I posted my reasons for Inora in the thread..

Nobody_Holme
February 9 2013, 02:24:15 PM
I disagree. The village won but they did not play well at all... Or did you forget zumwalt and nicho
Only reason village won that is thanks to bentguru being terrible too

I stand by nicho's play being smart in light of the info he had at the time, and will continue to do so. Also, bent being terrible was secondary to Me dropping some just-subtle-enough hints at the start and then holding his reveal for lategame, playing the perfect sheriff, while covered most of the game's duration because we had docs who knew what was going on.

Pacefalm
February 9 2013, 02:30:30 PM
The info Nicho had at the time was 2 people revealed themselves as having a power role. His response was to kill both of them.

Nicho Void
February 9 2013, 05:20:09 PM
The info Nicho had at the time was 2 people revealed themselves as having a power role. His response was to kill both of them.
Correct. One of them turned out to be lying. My read was spot on.

Bentguru
February 9 2013, 05:30:46 PM
The info Nicho had at the time was 2 people revealed themselves as having a power role. His response was to kill both of them.
Correct. One of them turned out to be lying. My read was spot on.

one was a villager providing coroner cover, the other was an actual coroner.

You got a power role + a villager killed, and yourself killed, resulting in a 3 for 0 exchange. Not a good result ldo

Nicho Void
February 9 2013, 05:39:42 PM
The info Nicho had at the time was 2 people revealed themselves as having a power role. His response was to kill both of them.
Correct. One of them turned out to be lying. My read was spot on.

one was a villager providing coroner cover, the other was an actual coroner.

You got a power role + a villager killed, and yourself killed, resulting in a 3 for 0 exchange. Not a good result ldo
The subsequent games have really displayed a much higher level of play, based on strong evidence and fact.

Or wait no, just blind guessing.

Bentguru
February 9 2013, 05:45:13 PM
The info Nicho had at the time was 2 people revealed themselves as having a power role. His response was to kill both of them.
Correct. One of them turned out to be lying. My read was spot on.

one was a villager providing coroner cover, the other was an actual coroner.

You got a power role + a villager killed, and yourself killed, resulting in a 3 for 0 exchange. Not a good result ldo
The subsequent games have really displayed a much higher level of play, based on strong evidence and fact.

Or wait no, just blind guessing.

IIRC you're the only person so far to lead a crusade to kill claimed power roles as a normal villager

Kilabi
February 9 2013, 05:53:05 PM
FHC, where you can read more about peopleīs role in mafia games in the OOG thread than you can in the game-thread.

Dorvil Barranis
February 9 2013, 08:23:46 PM
I plan on starting MAFIA - Alien Epidemic about a week after 40K starts. Couldn't figure out who it was that put there name on the list for the game after 40K, reading this thread, am thinking it was Nobody Holme. Nobody, let me know if you want to go before me, I think we might have the capacity to run more then one game concurrently, and I think mine might not last as long as 40K, even with starting a week afterwords.

I have a few more tweaks to the Alien Epidemic rules, but should be good for some mind games with the gradual switching of sides from Human to Epidemic.

Nobody_Holme
February 9 2013, 09:21:09 PM
I dont mind at all being delayed with mine.

It'd probably run a bit better after people play the more variant versions before it, to avoid coming into it with preconceptions, and also to weed out a few more dumb ideas from the general FHC subconcious. (also, i need more candidates for the masons, at the moment only three people have shown themselves to have what it takes to lead a villager faction properly.

Toxic
February 9 2013, 10:16:57 PM
So what specifically will the nut get when he investigates?

"Nut- Village. Thinks he's sheriff but receives bad info or failures for investigations."

Will it be totally random? exactly opposite with wrong roles? 90% fail?

Generally will be opposite. Failure and potentially correct just often enough to make the player believe he IS a sheriff.

Qwert
February 9 2013, 10:32:36 PM
The games would run so much better with simpler and very, very, explicit rules.


...And players that actually bothered to read them.